Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Vulnerable Subjects: Locating Research Ethics in/as Critical Praxis

Mon, April 11, 4:30 to 6:30pm, Marriott Marquis, Floor: Level Four, Liberty Salon N

Abstract

In this autoethnographic account, I critically examine experiences as a learner, teacher, and researcher situated across disciplinary boundaries and multiple institutions of higher education to address spatiotemporal and (trans)disciplinary dimensions of teaching critical research methodologies and ethics. In shifting between places and moments in my own learning process, I ask how ethics is differently located in curricular experiences based on disciplinary traditions and institutional histories, student and teacher positionalities, and critical research praxes.

My primary education in critical approaches to research and research ethics coincided (not coincidentally) with moving to and learning on Coast Salish lands. Always already a white settler (Snelgrove, Dhamoon, and Corntassel 2014), I came to understand myself as such through educational encounters with Indigenous peoples living on their lands, as well as through my coursework and graduate research training in an anthropology program that actively encouraged students to grapple with the discipline’s complicity in colonialism locally and globally. At the same time, engaging with decolonizing and feminist methodologies (cf. Smith 2012) provided additional guidance toward enacting critical self-reflexivity, embracing vulnerability as a part of my research praxis, and producing critical ethnography aimed at critiquing settler colonialism, white supremacy, and intersecting systems of power.

Moving again from Coast Salish to Amah Mutsun / Ohlone territories, my informal and formal teachers’ place-based pedagogies now inform my own research and teaching, prompting me to examine how best to support my students’ ethical development – and how to learn from them and from/with/in a new place (Tuck and McKenzie 2014). I also shifted from teaching on urban theory and linguistic culture in an anthropology program to teaching methods and writing in a critical race and ethnic studies program, bringing in a new host of challenges regarding how to teach ethics in an interdisciplinary and critical space. As the ‘where’ shifts, what are the implications for ethical education? How does one adopt and adapt place-based pedagogies in a new place, where systems of power persist yet take different shape? How does one facilitate students’ critical self-reflexivity as one’s own positionality also persists in systems of power yet takes new shape institutionally and disciplinarily? How do students’ subjectivities influence their own orientations and considerations of place, research, and ethics?

As Gaile S. Cannella and Yvonna Lincoln (2011) state, “Critical pedagogues focus on the underpinnings of power in whatever context they find themselves and the ways that power performs or is performed to create injustice.” They also argue that, “Research that would challenge oppression and foster social justice must acknowledge the gravity of context and the history of power within that context.” In addition to the who, the when and where of ethical education matters. This paper reflexively investigates how to ground a pedagogy of critical ethics in place and time to cultivate a more critical research praxis.

Author