Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Genre-Based Tensions From Writing and Commenting in Public Spaces: Are Blogs Rewarding or Rewarded?

Tue, April 12, 10:35am to 12:05pm, Convention Center, Floor: Level One, Room 151 A

Abstract

Objectives
Blogs are a platform for public writing and interaction. When compared to other forms of academic discourse, blogs are more dynamic than journals and less ephemeral than conferences. Blog posts are unlikely to be peer-reviewed prior to publication, and may not be acknowledged through formal channels (e.g., faculty evaluation processes) as scholarship. However, blogs written by scholars are cited in academic papers and read by academic and non-academic audiences. They also support the development and communication of networks. In this way, blogging is a rewarding, although not formally rewarded, practice. This paper explores three blog genres, noting how each promotes networking, serves a professional purpose, and creates professional tensions.

Perspectives
In this study, blogs written by academics are classified using a typology culled from earlier studies of blogs. The three types are research-oriented blogs (Kjellberg, 2010), public intellectual blogs (Kouper, 2010), and diaristic blogs (Dennen, 2014), a sub-genre of journal blogs (Herring, Scheidt, Bonus, & Wright, 2004). Activity systems analysis (Yamagata-Lynch, 2010) is used as an analytic framework to elucidate the objects and outcomes of bloggers as well as the tensions that affect their practices.

Methods
The research questions addressed by this study are:
1. How are different types of blog genres useful for academics as authors, audience, and networkers?
2. What tensions exist for academics participating in each genre?

Data Sources
These questions are addressed using data from two sources: 1) a data set (observations, field notes, interviews, and surveys) collected during a longitudinal ethnography of an academic blogging network, and 2) a collection of public blog posts written by academics about their blogging practices and representing all three types of blogs.

Data analysis focused on using these sources of evidence to construct activity systems for each genre. The activity – blogging – was broken into component parts (subject, rules, tool, community, division of labor, object, and outcome), which were used to code data, and then tensions among the parts were noted.

Results
Findings in this study show that research-oriented blogs can be useful for building networks within one’s discipline. Tensions in this genre include not scooping one’s own publications and pressure to post frequently. Public intellectual blogs are useful for spreading ideas, and may be confused by some people with research-oriented blogs, although the intent and content of each differs. Some bloggers find the public intellectual genre pushes them to assume a new role, often unfamiliar and sometimes not rewarded within the academy. Finally, diaristic blogs help academics reflect holistically on their careers and develop cross-disciplinary support networks. However, this genre leaves participants feeling vulnerable since they discuss their careers rather than topics within their academic disciplines.

Significance
These findings help us better understand how blogs are useful discourse and networking tools for academics. Although blogging may not be formally rewarded or recognized as a scholarly activity in any of these genres (and one might argue that in two of these genres it should), it nonetheless has sufficient reward to warrant the time and effort spent on the activity.

Author