Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Space, Place, and Identity: The New Pressures Experienced in the Lives of Young People

Sat, April 14, 8:15 to 10:15am, Millennium Broadway New York Times Square, Floor: Fourth Floor, Room 4.04-4.05

Abstract

Objectives or purposes
This paper seeks to examine the complex relationship between young people, social media and health and wellbeing through an analysis of issues related to space, place and identity. Young people’s engagements with social media and the resulting impact on their perceptions of self (with implications for health and well-being) will be considered within the context of the broader social worlds in which they live. A Bourdieusian framework is proposed to help understand the complex social landscapes of youth, the nature of the interactions that take place within/between particular social spaces (fields) and the influence of such engagements on the negotiation, construction and performance of identity.

Perspective(s) or theoretical framework
Drawing primarily on Bourdieu, but also work within the field of youth geographies around issues of spatiality (e.g. Blundell, 2016), we argue that the lives of young people in contemporary society are complex, multi-dimensional and characterised by an increasing sense of reflexivity and agency. Bourdieu’s work (Bourdieu, 1985, 1986, 1990) supports an understanding of young people’s daily lives being played out within a number of social fields, the structure of each being determined by the differentiation and distribution of various forms of capital. Young people’s capacity to acquire, consolidate or translate capital within/across different fields determines the nature of their social practice, which is then ‘written into the body’ via the habitus.



Data sources, evidence, objects or materials
The analysis was informed by data from the five composite narrative case studies (as presented in section 1). The case studies were analysed thematically to draw out key issues and concepts (e.g. Harry et al., 2005). The findings highlight a number of themes with regard to the relationships between young people, social media, health and well-being. Those discussed within this paper include: (1) how social media collapses the boundaries through which individuals typically socialise and thus acts as a distinct field and an extension of the social world; (2) the challenge of ‘fitting in’ and ‘standing out’ within intersecting fields and the exchange value of symbolic capital in this respect (in the form of ‘likes’ and ‘comments’); and (3) the presentation of the self and how social media offers another platform to create an imagined ideal and shape a ‘preferred’ identity.

Scientific or scholarly significance of the study or work
This paper draws on a Bourdieusian framework to offer fresh insight into the way in which individuals’ use of social media can shape their practice across a number of fields, influence their engagements with others and, potentially, impact their negotiation/construction of embodied identities. It points to the need for critical inquiry on the part of young people, and those who work with/for them, with regard to positive messages around health and well-being. It is argued that HPE, as a space that sits at the intersection of a number of key fields (e.g. physical culture, peers, school, media) and holds such significance for the construction of embodied identities (e.g. Fisette, 2011), is an important context in this respect.

Authors