Search
Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Room
Browse By Unit
Browse By Session Type
Search Tips
Annual Meeting Housing and Travel
Personal Schedule
Sign In
X (Twitter)
Objectives and Theoretical Framework:
Teams, rather than individuals, are commonly called upon to solve difficult problems in the workplace (Hackman, 1992). One area in which teams are core to the discipline and to academic programs is engineering design, which focuses on solving complex and ill-structured problems (DeChurch & Mesner-Magnus, 2010). Although design teams are commonplace in engineering, little is known about the role relational reasoning plays in performance or how instructional programs might be better devised to enhance such reasoning. The limited research that does exist suggests that design teams exhibit various forms of relational reasoning, including analogical (similarity), anomalous (deviation), antithetical (opposition), and antinomous (incompatibility) reasoning (Christensen & Ball, 2016; Dumas et al. 2014). However, there is limited understanding about how forms of relational reasoning play out as teams actively engage in problem solving or how the effectiveness of teams reflects their reasoning patterns. Without such a critical baseline, it is not evident how instructional programs involving design teams can be reconfigured to ensure their effectiveness. For that reason, the current investigation undertook variable- and person-centered analyses to explore the occurrence of relational reasoning within and between teams and to characterize teams on the basis of a cluster of variables related to facets of reasoning patterns, team discourse, and design quality indicators.
Method and Data Sources:
Participants were three teams (n=17) of undergraduates enrolled in a senior engineering design course. Teams were videotaped in their first three meetings, which took place outside of class. In these meetings, teams were tasked with conceptualizing ten viable designs, then narrowing those down to three, and then to one. Content analysis was performed on student discourse by coding relational reasoning utterances using a framework developed by Dumas et al. (2014). In addition to reasoning data, information collected included the quality of ideas (i.e., innovativeness, viability) forwarded by each team, two graded reports, and final course grades.
Results:
For the variable-centered analyses, chi-square tests of independence revealed that all four forms of relational reasoning were present but were disproportionally verbalized across meetings and teams. Further, a transition matrix demonstrated that certain forms of relational reasoning transitioned to other forms with a higher frequency than expected by chance. To explore the unfolding of relational reasoning in more depth, a sequence mining tool was constructed. The tool revealed that analogies sparked more analogies in strings of up to six, and antinomies lead to strings of analogies or antitheses. For the person-centered analysis, we characterized the three teams using the available data as highly efficient, moderately effective, and disparate reasoners/designers. The presentation concludes with implications for course development.
Scientific Significance:
This in vivo study is the first, to our knowledge, to examine manifestations of relational reasoning forms during team problem solving. Findings revealed that team effectiveness in engineering design was supported by the usage of different forms of reasoning in concert that helped in task completion. Importantly, these findings serve as a baseline upon which future curricular enhancements might be considered.
Sophie Jablansky, University of Maryland - College Park
Patricia A. Alexander, University of Maryland - College Park
Linda Schmidt