Search
Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Room
Browse By Unit
Browse By Session Type
Search Tips
Annual Meeting Housing and Travel
Personal Schedule
Sign In
X (Twitter)
Numerous studies in science education have started to explore more closely the social production of girls in science in light of their mobility and entanglement in multiple space-time configurations of institutions, practices, and place through the lens of history in person and local contentious practice (e.g., Carlone et al., 2016; Holland & Lave, 2009; Tan et al, 2013; Thompson, 2014). Building on this theoretical stance, we became interested in the notion of wayfaring, introduced by Ingold (2011), which assumes that it is “in their movement along a way of life – that people grow into knowledge” (p. 162). This led to two questions: 1) How learning and identity are part of ongoing social arrangements and relations; and 2) How we may understand identity in science through a mobility lens and as wayfaring.
To rethink “equal educational opportunity” as called for by AERA, we first tried to step away from the linear science career pipeline model and focus on ways girls actually navigate science practices and continuously negotiate their identity in science in light of their figured worlds, positioning and authoring of self (Holland et al., 1998). Building on mobility theory (Sheller, 2011), we explored resources and places that were sought out, mobilized or resisted in support of new ways of becoming in science.
We pursued a two-year ethnographic case study of a scientific newsletter activity in Les Scientifines from 2009-2011, an afterschool science program for girls only in an underserved community of Montreal, Canada. From 2012 – 2016, we met every year with a subgroup of six girls of the program (in 2016, ranging in age from 17 to 21; with parents who immigrated from Trinidad, St. Lucie, Bangladesh, Sri Lanka & Morocco). In this paper, we focus primarily on a cartography project and follow up discussion we pursued together in the winter of 2016. Through inductive content analysis of the cartography and conversation, we identified contentious moments and tensions that shed light on “meshworks” tied to the relations and social structures the girls’ mobility made available to them.
Through sustained engagement in Les Scientifines, the six girls developed a “relational solidarity” that they built on beyond the program through the development of an informal affinity group (McKenzie & Bieler, 2016). Our annual meetings became extensions of that space in which contentious moments could be safely discussed. To be first-generation college bound and the only woman of color in a University program while also having little in common with others in higher education was one tension we explored. That tension was further complicated by intergenerational family struggles and experienced cultural discontinuities given the girls' immigration history. The discussions helped us focus on the ways the girls’ “lives are led not inside places but through, around, to and from them” (Ingold, 2011, p. 148). We offer some suggestions about “wayfaring” in science and propose a nonlinear multidimensional model of becoming in science with important implications for action.
Jrene Rahm, University of Montreal
Allison Gonsalves, McGill University
Audrey Lamothe-Lachaîne, Université de Montréal