Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Literacy, Feeling, and the Inhuman

Sat, April 14, 8:15 to 9:35am, Millennium Broadway New York Times Square, Floor: Fourth Floor, Room 4.11

Abstract

Objectives

This paper returns literacy to its affective beginning in the infant’s literacy (Grumet, 1988). In infancy literacy is the child’s attempt to symbolically communicate feeling. As she is given words to names these feelings the child learns to engage in man-made symbols that form, reform, and deform her unique sense of self. To locate literacy in its felt beginnings I turn to three cases where affect exceeds symbolic-driven notions of literacy.

Theoretical framework

In education literacy is conceived as a cognitive process fostering the intellectual ability to decode discrete alphabetical symbols. The literacy industry, based in the colonizing imperatives of English education and supported by cognitive psychology, touches every part of a child’s K-12 education; every part of a child’s mental, emotional, intellectual, social and physical development is subject to the man-made practice of literacy. In his essay The Inhuman Jean Francois Lyotard suggests that technologies of Man, as is literacy, are dehumanizing as they fail to attend to the whole and relational felt existence of the infant. My paper refinds literacy in this pre-colonial, animal, in-human, relational worldless state. Drawing from child psychoanalysis (Britzman, 2016; Klein, 1921), post-structuralism (Lyotard, 1992; Derrida, 2002) and postcolonial theory (Spivak, 2012) my paper will reconstruct the time of literacy as one that constantly refers back to the child’s ‘grasp of the world’ through feeling (Spivak, 2012).

Methods

The paper will use three literacy predicaments to position literacy as fundamentally a felt, interpretive, intra and inter subjective experience that is overwritten by words that effaces its affective stirring. The first case is of a man, Jacques Derrida (2002), who holds a wordless conversation with his cat. The second case is of Little Fritz (Klein, 1921), a child whose excessive existential and/or sexual questions convey a child’ literacy, one that J-B Pontalis describes as “having more to say for himself than he actually said” (in Stonebridge & Phillips, 1998). The third case is of Mary Johnson, an Indigenous elder who wishes to sing her testimony of a land claim in court to a Supreme Court judge who claims he cannot literally hear what she is saying (in Pinder, 2001).


Significance

Analysis of these cases will demonstrate the educational need to reconceive literacy as beginning with the felt life of the inhuman rather than the symbolic an/or intellectual life of the English male adult. When literacy is viewed as a technology that overwrites the first inhuman nature through the instrumental delivering of words that approximate feeling without attesting for it, it voids language of the possible meaning symbolic communication can hold for us all. To ground literacy in its inhuman condition is to relocate symbolic development in its affective beginning the wellspring of all thinking, acting, and existing with each other (Springgay, & Freedman, 2012)

Author