Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Responses to School Shootings: Well-Meaning or Just Plain Mean?

Sun, April 15, 8:15 to 10:15am, New York Hilton Midtown, Floor: Second Floor, Gramercy Room East

Abstract

There was a time not very long ago when the "Three R's" was a well-known and rather catchy reference to the trilogy of basic skills (I.e., reading, 'riting and 'rithmetic). But over the past quarter century, several major shockwaves involving multiple-victim school shootings have put the concern for student safety and security on par with scholastics. In the modern day climate of fear, the "Three R's" has also become about the risk, readiness and response with regard to gun violence.
In this presentation, we offer a sobering overview of the nature, patterns and trends in school shootings that have occurred since the early 1990s when gang bangers, not active shooters, were the focus of school security initiatives. The data presented include the overall incidence and victimization rate of episodes in which students or school personnel are fatally shot, be it by an insider or an intruder. The analysis clearly shows that by any measure and against any basis for comparison, schools are safe, and for many youngsters, safer even than their own homes.
Despite the relative safety of schools, certain high-profile incidents, such as the 1999 Columbine High massacre and the 2012 Sandy Hook Elementary School shooting, have created a level of fear that is generally out of proportion to the risk. The frequent media hype about school rampages has resulted in a variety of knee-jerk responses that are of questionable value. We describe and assess a range of security measures that have become commonplace in American schools, including video surveillance systems, zero tolerance suspension policies, school resource officers, emergency drills, protective school gear, arming teachers, and anti-bullying programs.
Unfortunately, many of these well-meaning strategies have mean-spirited outcomes, including the so-called “school to prison pipeline” that especially impacts minority populations. Alternative approaches that focus instead on school design, climate, and size are also discussed as a way to enhance security without unnecessarily increasing the level of anxiety. The overall message is to avoid easy solutions that don’t work in favor of difficult ones that will.

Authors