Search
Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Room
Browse By Unit
Browse By Session Type
Search Tips
Annual Meeting Housing and Travel
Personal Schedule
Sign In
X (Twitter)
There is a growing consensus that sustained, rigorous talk in the classroom develops English Learners’ (ELs’) deep and generative knowledge of conceptual, analytical, and language practices (Valdés, Kibler & Walqui, 2014; Walqui & van Lier, 2010). Socioculturalists propose that learning takes place in two planes, first in the social plane through interaction with others, and then in the mental plane, as practices become appropriated by apprentices and are appropriately applied to novel situations. In this view, social interaction is a condition of development (Vygotsky, 1987; van Lier, 1996; Lantolf & Thorne, 2006). However, classroom talk that leads to productive activity for all students, and especially for ELs, is not easy to obtain. The purpose of this paper is three-fold: to present a sociocultural view of language development as occurring ecologically with affordances and conditions needed to engage ELs in substantive, rigorous subject matter interaction; to address the challenges in the design and enactment of these ecological engagements; and to illustrate the application of the model in contexts where ELs are learning disciplinary practices in secondary schools.
An ecological view of the development of second language practices has at its heart negotiated interaction: on the one hand among persons within an environment and on the other between such persons and that environment. Central to ecology is the construct of affordances, both positive and negative for language acquisition which arise through social, semiotic, and linguistic interaction (van Lier, 1988; 1996). Considering affordances allows educators to view interaction as more than input/output, highlighting the negotiation of meaning as revealing the learning process at work. Ecological approaches study language development as resulting from variability in affordances, the language learning opportunities that exist in the environment. Focus is placed on the relations of thought, action and power rather than on objects (words, sentences, rules) and on the consideration of verbal utterances as related to gestures, intonation, drawings and artifacts, all of which organically provide clues to the unfolding of learning opportunities.
A focus on affordances enables educators to address four challenges facing the design and enactment of interactive pedagogical practices with ELs: 1) the limited opportunities they are offered to engage in discourse around disciplinary constructs (Walqui et al, 2009); 2) the lack of attention to ELs’ need to develop a conscious understanding of their evolving understanding and how to improve on it; 3) the notion that teachers need to be the initiators and managers of interaction with and among students in the classroom, leading to IRF or IRA type of interactions; and 4) the belief that productive interaction necessitates a “more capable” person at performing the task interacting with a “less capable” one (Clarke, 2015).
Drawing from classroom data in middle and high schools, the paper elaborates on the impact of considering the variable affordances available to ELs in the process of developing the academic uses of English. In doing so, it presents a solution to the problems of unequal classroom interaction and inequitable results in the second language classroom.