Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Between Public Good and Private Interests: Exploring the Values of Public Education in Taiwan

Sun, April 15, 2:45 to 4:15pm, New York Hilton Midtown, Floor: Fourth Floor, Lincoln Suite

Abstract

Over the past few decades, Taiwanese society has rapidly become much more heterogeneous. How to respond to this sudden social heterogeneity is now an emerging issue, both socially and educationally. For both parents and educators, education is seen as a path for upward social mobility, a means for practicing the ideals of democracy, and a tool for pursuing economic prosperity. However, public education, once seen as a basic right of all citizens, is now facing many challenges resulting from the government’s neo-liberal reform policies. Major policy initiatives, such as those promoting deregulation, school choice, and market competition, are creating a new social space in which particular social relations of the school are built up, but are also contributing to a new unevenness of educational opportunity. Therefore, how the public education system responds to this emerging social heterogeneity is an interesting and crucial question. There are multiple approaches and perspectives for exploring how the public education system responds to social heterogeneity, such as historical, institutional, and social analysis. In this paper I categorize these approaches and perspectives into two groups: top-down and bottom-up. The top-down approach explores how education deals with social heterogeneity by analyzing national education reform policy in terms of how it responds to the call for social equality. However, there is another path for exploring the values of public schooling, that is, from the perspective of the everyday life of parents and educators at public schools, an approach which illustrates how parents and educators react and interact when faced with new reform policies affecting public education. I call this the bottom-up approach.
In this paper I apply the bottom-up approach to explore how the public values of schooling work in tandem with the private interests of (dis)advantaged parents and educators. This is to say that the values of public education are truly embodied in different contexts of public junior high schools by local parents and educators. Employing the research methodology of ethnography, I investigated two schools which are relatively disadvantaged in comparison to popular urban schools. I participated in the schools’ administrative meetings and parents’ councils, and interviewed their principals, teachers, and parents. In this paper I describe each case in general and analyze how the values of public education are embodied by parents and educators in the different contexts of these two schools. Finally, I discuss how parental involvement and educators’ middle-class approach to educational management further the interests of particular groups of students, rather than public good; in effect, the public good discourse is exploited to promote the interests of certain groups of parents and educators. As a result, the implementation of reform policy at the school level turns out to work against the implementation of the government’s education reform policies intended to benefit disadvantaged schools.

Author