Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Associations Between Pattern Understanding and Early Arithmetic and Reading Skills

Tue, April 17, 2:15 to 3:45pm, Millennium Broadway New York Times Square, Floor: Seventh Floor, Room 7.01

Abstract

Introduction
Measures of patterning correlate concurrently with measures of arithmetic (e.g. Lee et al., 2011, 2012) and reading (e.g. Pasnak et al., 2016) and there is some evidence that training patterning skills leads to gains in these skills (e.g. Kidd et al., 2014). However much of this evidence is complicated by the use of pattern tasks which use number and letter patterns: relationships between such measures and arithmetic and reading potentially just reflect alphanumeric knowledge. Furthermore, only one study provides longitudinal evidence that patterning predicts later arithmetic (Rittle-Johnson et al., 2016); critically this study did not include measures of executive function or general intelligence, both of which correlate with patterning. In this study, we examine patterning as a concurrent and longitudinal predictor of arithmetic and reading beyond the contribution of a wide range of theoretically critical cognitive skills.

Methods
A large sample of children (N=569) from 11 primary schools in Brisbane, Australia, were assessed three times at approximately six-monthly intervals from the outset of formal schooling (Mage = 5 years, 3 months). At each time point, children were assessed on a wide range of numeracy (counting, number knowledge, magnitude comparison, and early arithmetic) and reading (word reading, letter-sound knowledge, phonological awareness and RAN) measures, tests of executive functioning (working memory, attention, inhibition and visual short-term memory), non-verbal IQ (t1 only) and patterning (t2 and t3). Three patterning tasks asked children to select one of four answers to complete patterns consisting of letters, numbers and colours, objects, and shapes.

Results
Latent variable path models were constructed to examine a wide range of putative cognitive foundations for arithmetic and reading. In these models, alphanumeric patterning (letters and numbers) was separated from non-alphanumeric patterning (objects, colours and shapes): the two patterning latent variables were strongly correlated (r = .69) but could be meaningfully distinguished. At Time 2, arithmetic was predicted by addition (t1), executive function (t2) and non-alphanumeric patterning (t2). Reading was predicted by early reading (t1), number knowledge (t1), and non-alphanumeric patterning (t2). In addition to the direct effect from EF (t2) to arithmetic (t2) there was also an indirect effect (EF non-alphanumeric patterning arithmetic) which was significant (standardized indirect effect = 0.105, p < 0.001). Similarly, though EF (t2) has no direct effect on reading (t2) there was an indirect effect (EF non-alphanumeric patterning reading) which was significant (standardized indirect effect = 0.066, p < 0.001). Overall, the model accounts for 85% of the variance in arithmetic and 78% of the variance in reading. (T3 data collection has recently been completed; these data will also be reported and discussed.)

Conclusion
Non-alphanumeric patterning is a unique predictor of arithmetic and reading after controlling for a wide range of theoretically critical skills, including EF. These relationships between pattern understanding and the development of arithmetic and reading require further large-scale longitudinal studies to explore them.

Authors