Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Authoring as a Metaphor for Theorizing Identity (Re)Formation in High School Mathematics

Sun, April 15, 2:45 to 4:15pm, The Parker, Floor: Third Floor, Tansa 1 Room

Abstract

Purpose
Metaphors help us make sense of complex phenomena (Lakoff & Johnson, 2003). In mathematics education, the primary metaphor of “constructing” tends to foreground content and cognition to the effect of minimizing the student as a person being shaped by experiences. Through research in several high schools in Western Canada, I have observed a reciprocity between students’ identity (re)formation and mathematical learning (Author1, Author2, Author3). I report on a project with high school students who engaged in learning-to-learn mathematics by actively shaping learning processes. I aim to offer a metaphor to disrupt current discourse in order to reimagine a purpose for mathematics learning, which honours students’ identity formation.

Perspective
Dewey’s (1938/1997) notion of educative experiences frames the study conceptually. Within pragmatism as a philosophical orientation, I drew on Blumer’s (1954) sensitizing concepts from symbolic interactionism to inform both the design of opportunities for students to improve their learning processes and the data interpretation. My sensitizing concepts include: intention/al/ity, voice, (re)forming identity, and epistemological stance.

Method & Data Sources
Constructivist grounded theory (Charmaz, 2014) framed this interpretive inquiry. Located in a Canadian urban school, thirteen grade 12 students from Mathematical Learning Skills class, taken concurrently with Pure Mathematics, participated. Data constructed over four months included interactive writing, small group working sessions, two individual interviews with students and the teacher, student working papers, and field notes.

Coding was theoretically informed by my sensitizing concepts, with over 120 codes developed during three passes through the data using the constant comparative method (Glaser & Strauss, 1967). Categories of analysis were developed through prototypical exemplars (Dey, 2010). I developed three analytic frameworks, which explicated related categories concerning students’ learning: learning-based conversations, developing learning processes, and making sense of mathematics ideas.

Results
By identifying the interrelationships among the analytic frameworks, I theorized that students’ learning and growth could be understood through a metaphor of authoring. In mathematics education, authoring of self is seen as a component part of identity formation (Graven, 2012). I propose that authoring is explanatory of an ontological orientation toward mathematical learning more broadly. Through experiences of learning, the learner is in the process of being and becoming.

Authoring is a generative activity of making meaning of experiences, implicating the author in self-making through expressing understanding with an emerging authoritative voice to an audience. In the final interview, Laurel explained in three related moments, “it was nice to figure out that I can—do it”; “I’ve figured out what works best for me” in her process of learning math; and, that high school was “about learning to learn.” Laurel exemplifies on behalf of her peers that students voiced self-authoring as individuals capable of doing mathematics, learning mathematics, and learning to learn mathematics.

Scholarly significance
The metaphor of authoring occasions a way to attend to the learner as the one authoring himself/herself into the world – an ontological orientation to learning concerned with becoming. Understanding learning in mathematics through the metaphor of authoring could invigorate a powerful shift toward humanizing mathematical learning.

Author