Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Beyond National Identity: On Being Muslim and Bantu—Implications for U.S. School Context

Sat, April 14, 4:05 to 6:05pm, Park Central Hotel New York, Floor: Mezzanine Level, Carnegie

Abstract

Objectives or purposes
This paper draws from the lived stories of Somali Bantu youth in an urban high school in the Midwest to highlight how race is taken up within the immigrant Somali community. In Somalia, Bantus are marginalized and discriminated against because of their physical features, which according to Somalis are more African (Eno & Kusow, 2014). The discourses surrounding the status of Somali Bantus persist in the Diaspora, including in the Midwestern Somali immigrant community highlighted in this study. For young Somali Bantu in U.S. schools, old boundaries of Somaliness haunt them as they interact with Somali school staff and students. Therefore, the purpose of this study was to shed light on nuanced and complex processes of racialization that are rooted in narratives of Somaliness and western racial hierarchies that depend on phonotypical characteristics. To date, scholarly literature is void of research on school leadership practices that best serve students who are minoritized both in their indigenous contexts and in the United States. This study is a unique contribution to understanding the invisibilized status of being minoritized within one’s own “immigrant” community.

Perspective(s) or theoretical framework
This qualitative study examined the experiences and socialization of Somali students in an urban school in the Midwest. Guiding the inquiry was Kusow and Eno’s (2014) formulaic narratives of Somaliness. These are constructed narratives that create boundaries of inclusion and exclusion, from structural to cultural standpoints. Kusow and Eno’s (2014) work examines the multiple ways in which the construction of these formulaic narratives shape the lives of Somali Bantu.

Methods, techniques, or modes of inquiry
I employed ethnographic methods in collecting interview data from students and school staff as well as field observation both at the school and in a community center.

Data Sources, evidence, objects or materials
A total of 25 students, three teachers, two teacher aids, one school administrator, and two community workers were interviewed.

Results and/or substantiated conclusions or warrants for arguments/point of view
The results of this study indicated the continuous effect that racializing narratives have on the Somali identity in the diaspora. I argue the violence and alienation caused by these narratives not only impact the Somali Bantu and other minorities in the Somali community, but they also alienate Somalis from joining the political struggles inherent in a multicultural society such as those in North America and other the Western countries.

Scientific or scholarly significance of the study or work
This research has significance for both research and practice. The arguments in this paper push the field of antiracist education to consider discourses of othering within the Muslim and immigrant communities. Researchers and practitioners need to be aware that immigrant and refugee communities, hailing from same nations, are not homogenous and sometimes can reproduce oppressive practices that are not known to mainstream educators. This, therefore is extremely relevant to AERA’s theme as it recognizes the perspectives and knowledge of historically marginalized peoples.

Author