Search
Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Room
Browse By Unit
Browse By Session Type
Search Tips
Annual Meeting Housing and Travel
Personal Schedule
Sign In
X (Twitter)
The goal complex model is emerging as a useful and generative framework for studying achievement goals, capable even of unifying opposing perspectives within the field (Senko & Tropiano, 2016). The model fuses achievement goals with higher-order motives for engaging in tasks. It posits that students pursue mastery(-approach) or performance(-approach) goals for a variety of reasons, and also that those reasons shape a goal’s effects downstream (Elliot & Thrash, 2001; Vansteenkiste et al., 2014). A performance goal, for example, is sometimes pursued to make tasks fun or to boost pride, and in these cases it provides relatively desirable outcomes; that same goal, however, is other times pursued to earn approval, and in those cases it brings undesirable outcomes.
To this point, goal complex research has emphasized personal motives for goal pursuit; social motives have been overlooked or deemed “controlling” and unhealthy. This study explores whether students pursue potentially healthy socially-anchored achievement goal complexes. In considering social motives, we turned to research on first-generation college students (FGS), who, more so than continuing-generation students (CGS), go to college for multiple reasons: not just personal ones geared toward personal development and exploring interests, but also prosocial ones geared toward (a) pleasing and honoring their family and (b) being a role model and servant to their own community. We tested whether those three higher-order motives fuse with either achievement goal into a goal complex, guiding students’ downstream educational experience.
University students (108 FGS, 129 CGS) completed an online survey that assessed their motives for entering college (personal, community, and family), performance and mastery goals, and two desirable (self-efficacy, interest) and two undesirable (self-handicapping, help avoidance) educational outcomes.
Replicating past work (e.g., Tibbetts et al., 2016), FGS and CGS both reported strong personal motives for attending college, but only FGS also had strong family and community motives. We used regression analyses to identify goal complexes, which would entail a school motive being both an antecedent of a goal’s pursuit and a moderator of that goal’s effects. Results showed a previously unidentified performance goal complex (see Figure 1). Performance goal pursuit traced in part to family honor motives, and the goal’s downstream effects also depended on whether students held strong family honor motives: those who did (e.g., FGS) derived greater benefits with the performance goal. Mastery goal pursuit, by contrast, traced to strong personal motives and community service motives, and this goal produced its usual array of beneficial outcomes regardless of underlying school motives.
These findings extend prior goal complex research by demonstrating that achievement goals can cluster with varied personal and social motives and, more importantly, that some of those social motives can form healthy goal complexes that provide beneficial educational outcomes. This highlights the need to identify the full range of goal motives. It also suggests the goal complex model could boost long-standing theoretical efforts to integrate students’ achievement and social academic goals (e.g., Liem, 2016; Wentzel, 2000).