Search
Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Room
Browse By Unit
Browse By Session Type
Search Tips
Annual Meeting Housing and Travel
Personal Schedule
Sign In
X (Twitter)
Consistently across meta-analyses conducted on achievement goal research, performance-avoidance goals (aiming at not performing more poorly than one’s peers) are shown to exert a negative impact on achievement (e.g., Murayama & Elliot, 2012). Late research focused on assessing whether pursuing some achievement goals for different reasons could alter their predictive validity (e.g. Senko & Tropiano, 2016). Yet, only little work has focused so far on studying the effects of performance-avoidance goals from this perspective. The present research draws from the social value approach (Dompnier, Darnon, & Butera, 2009, 2013), which posits that achievement goals may be pursued for two non-exclusive and socially determined reasons: social desirability (to please one’s teachers) and social utility (to succeed at university). Specifically, we investigated in two studies whether pursuing performance-avoidance goals would be predictive of different consequences on achievement depending on their underlying reason related with the social utility ingredient of social value. Past research has suggested that pursuing achievement goals for social utility reasons exacerbate their genuine effects on achievement (Dompnier et al., 2009, 2013). Hence, insofar as performance-avoidance goals exert a negative impact on achievement, we hypothesized that endorsing these goals for social utility reasons would exacerbate their negative effect on achievement. We tested this prediction using a correlational design (Study 1) and an experimental design (Study 2).
In Study 1, 149 students first completed a practice anagram task (baseline measure of achievement) and reported their spontaneous endorsement of performance-avoidance goals in this task. We then asked them to answer the same scale under social utility instructions: they were asked to report their endorsement of performance-avoidance goals as if they were to demonstrate that they had all the qualities required to succeed at University in the eyes of their teachers. This procedure enables to measure students’ beliefs about the social utility of performance-avoidance goals and allows monitoring the degree to which they are inclided to pursue these goals for social utility reasons (cf. Dompnier et al., 2013). Finally, participants performed a second anagram task (achievement measure). In line with our hypothesis, results showed that the more students endorsed performance-avoidance goals for social utility reasons, the more these goals predicted negatively their achievement.
In Study 2, 126 students first completed a practice anagram task (baseline measure of achievement). Then, they were randomly assigned to two experimental conditions manipulating performance-avoidance goals’ social utility: they read a bogus article stating that performance-avoidance goals either positively predict academic achievement (high social utility) or they do not (low social utility). They then reported their performance-avoidance goal endorsement in the task and performed a second anagram task (achievement measure). Consistently with our prediction, results showed that pursuing performance-avoidance goals was more deleterious on students’ achievement in the “high social utility” condition than in the “low social utility” condition.
Our research thus provides evidence that social utility reasons underlying performance-avoidance goals can moderate the predictive validity of these goals.