Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Responding to Student Errors During Classroom Discussion: Deliberate Opportunities to Support Teacher Candidate Development

Sat, April 14, 12:25 to 1:55pm, The Parker, Floor: Third Floor, Tansa 1 Room

Abstract

Objectives and Perspectives

One challenge when leading whole-class discussions is responding when student contributions include mathematical errors. Skillfully responding involves noticing errors, treating them as instances of sense-making, and mobilizing students to make sense of and build understanding from errors (Bray, 2011; Kazemi & Stipek, 2001). This work is complex and difficult for teachers (e.g., Schleppenbach, Flevares, Sims, & Perry, 2007). We consider how teacher candidates (TCs) might develop skill with responding to errors through purposeful opportunities to approximate and reflect on practice (e.g., Grossman et al., 2009). We investigate the use of coached rehearsals of instructional activities (IA; McDonald et al., 2013) designed for TCs to approximate interactive practices. Rehearsals can afford opportunities for supporting elementary TCs’ reasoning and skill development around responding to student thinking (Lampert et al., 2013). We extend this to the secondary level and focus on designing opportunities for TCs to develop skill in responding to errors during discussions.

Methods

The study occurred in secondary methods courses at two institutions. We used a sorting task IA (Authors, 2016) where students sorted examples and non-examples of an object (e.g., equations and non-equations) to develop a definition. Students, played by TCs, shared in whole-class discussion objects they found easy and difficult to sort and reasoned about them. Each rehearsal also included a “planted error”—a student contribution intentionally designed to create an opportunity to respond to an error. Data include videos of rehearsals, TCs written reflections, and TCs annotations of the rehearsal video. We analyzed how rehearsals offered opportunities for TCs to learn to respond productively to errors and how they reflected on their practice.

Results

The planted errors provided valuable opportunities to work on responding to errors. TCs reflected on feeling surprised by them, and some requested in-the-moment coaching during their rehearsals to help them respond productively. TCs sometimes responded differently to contributions with errors than to correct contributions, and these differences were discussed when debriefing the rehearsals. Relatedly, the IA structure provided opportunities for TCs to work on responding to incorrect or incomplete reasoning by asking students for boundary cases during the discussion. In-the-moment coaching also created opportunities to learn. Coaching included supporting mathematical sense-making, problematizing ways of responding to errors (e.g., addressing the instinct to immediately correct students), and discussing ways to use errors to support collective sense-making. Finally, TC reflections revealed they took up ideas about responding to errors, and how they sought to balance a desire to have an error corrected quickly with treating that error as an opportunity for sense making—a balance that is complex and is an area for further investigation.

Scholarly Significance

Rehearsals offer opportunities to work on knowledge, practices, and dispositions in an integrated way (Lampert et al., 2013). We provide an example of how such opportunities can be targeted to specific instructional work—responding to errors—through the design and use of an IA. This is especially important because how errors are handled is consequential for students and challenging for teachers.

Authors