Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Gender Diversity Is a Strength: A Policy Discourse Analysis of University Transgender Inclusion Action

Mon, April 16, 4:05 to 5:35pm, New York Marriott Marquis, Floor: Fourth Floor, Brecht

Abstract

Policy discourse analysis provides a theoretical framework for understanding the conversation regarding transgender people on university campuses (Fischer, 1980; Pillow, 2003). Allan defines the term policy discourse analysis as “an explicit focus on policy discourses and the discursive shaping of subjects’ positions through policy” (2003, p. 49). Feminist approaches to policy analysis (Allan, Iverson, & Ropers-Huilman, 2010) can be used to examine the documents that were produced while an institution was contemplating the status of transgender people, adding gender identity and expression to a nondiscrimination statement, or the campus climate for LGBTQ people.
The first university to add gender identity and expression to its nondiscrimination policy was the University of Iowa in 1996; as of July 2017 this number increased to 1,036 campuses across the United States (Campus Pride, 2017). Many institutions have changed their non-discrimination policies and offer concomitant support for transgender individuals, students in particular. Since this is a relatively new and expanding phenomenon, to date, limited scholarship has examined why such policy changes have occurred and how, despite seemingly benefitting transgender people, the discourses carried by the documents that discuss trans people may actually undermine the intended goals of the policy initiatives (Allan, 2008). For example, a university’s report on the status of transgender people may use language depicting them as vulnerable or as disabled, even as it strives to make the university more welcoming to trans individuals. Understanding how language has been used to describe transgender people on university campuses may help these institutions reflect on how to change the campus climate to welcome gender diverse people and provide the policy and practical tools in order to do so.
There are competing discourses in diversity action plans, but they often default to depictions of people as objects being acted upon on as a commodity, and less frequently as individuals with agency who can act autonomously and influence the institution from this discursive position (Iverson, 2010). It should be noted that, historically, the trans story is also one that is largely a white story; we rarely hear the voices of trans people of color (Marine, 2011). These individuals are not invisible, but their voices are not heard in the university reports in this study. The voices of trans people of color are present in some secondary sources, and they speak to a intersectional marginalization due to white supremacy and transphobia (Al-Walid, 2010; Tokawa, 2010).
My aim is to identify predominant discourses taken up to depict trans people, and what reality is produced by the reports. The following research questions framed this study: (a) What are the predominant images of transgender people that emerge from university reports? and (b) What discourses are employed to shape these images? My hope is that this article provides a roadmap for what pitfalls institutions should avoid and what model they should aspire to, particularly by looking at the discourses used.

Author