Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

District-Charter Collaboration and Instructional Practice Sharing

Tue, April 17, 12:25 to 1:55pm, Park Central Hotel New York, Floor: Mezzanine Level, Manhattan A Room

Abstract

From what began as the “R&D” alternative to traditional public schools over 20 years ago, charter schools now account for significant portions of student enrollment in many cities and traditional districts. In over 190 districts, charter attendance makes up 10% of the student enrollment, and in 17 districts, over 30%. As enrollment grows, the result of traditional districts and charter sectors operating in isolation or, more commonly, with hostility and distrust, falls squarely on the shoulders of students and families through byzantine enrollment systems and timelines, lack of accountability around equity issues, inequitable funding, or just missed opportunities to share their best. Increasingly, however, cities have chosen to forge partnerships to address these common challenges and share practices.

During this session, researchers will present findings from the past six years of studying 23 cities that have formalized partnerships through Gates-funded District-Charter Collaboration Compacts, as well as cities that have pursued partnerships outside of formal Compacts. Based on phone and field interviews with education leaders and tracking of numerous efforts, we found that collaborative work falls into several categories, and there are a set of preconditions that, when present, increase the likelihood that the collaboration efforts will be successful and sustained. We will then focus on the preconditions and barriers particular to sharing instructional practices, a strategy some cities employ to begin collaborative work and build the conditions for larger-scale efforts.

We will start by describing the typology of district-charter collaboration efforts and the continuum of costs to implement versus potential benefit to district/charter sector and/or families and students. While the potential impact, especially on families, of a system-wide change such as unified enrollment, is large, the costs of implementation is a considerable barrier for cities that are not positioned to make such a move. We will share what we have found are the enabling factors for collaboration, including:

● Leaders willing to champion the cause
● A win-win: something to benefit both sides
● Benefits for the effort outweigh the costs
● A plan for sustainability
● Governance to push the effort forward
● A way to measure effectiveness
● Funding available to support the effort

One strategy cities have used to build goodwill, trust, and establish a proof-point for further work is to start small, which is why many cities approached collaboration through sharing instructional practices. This can take the form of shared professional development programs or shared teacher or leader training pipelines. While not necessarily the highest-impact activity compared to other options, cross-sector practice sharing can not only set the tone for future work, but restores an original benefit of charters as laboratories of innovation. After sharing examples of instructional-practice sharing, we will discuss the barriers to this work and recommendations for implementing successful programs.

Through this presentation, we hope to give practitioners and policymakers interested in pursuing cross-sector work a toolkit to consider approaches and a framework for understanding the factors underpinning successful efforts.

Authors