Search
Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Room
Browse By Unit
Browse By Session Type
Search Tips
Annual Meeting Housing and Travel
Personal Schedule
Sign In
X (Twitter)
Contemporary teacher education employs the observation of teaching as a “method” to develop professional teachers. Novice teachers, whose eyes are “not-yet” ready to see the expert teaching, are trained to develop their eyes to “professionally see” teaching as complex but seemingly effortless practice. With trust that teaching could be broken down into its constituent parts, observation provides the methods for teaching of teaching, through the step-by-step processes; firstly “representing and decomposing the best teaching” then “approximating”, to fill the gap from the novice to the professional teacher (Grossman et al., 2009). Observation, as a reliable method of training teachers, suggests developmental strategies with observation feedback; however, the promise of observation and feedback is questionable in that the “kind of feedback” that teachers receive for development is already “framed largely by the categories of the observation instruments” (Hill and Grossman, 2013, p. 379).
This study genealogically traces the emergence of “systematic” approaches of observation in teacher education. Specifically, this paper examines how the Cold War rationality of cybernetic feedback (Halpern, 2014) entered into American teacher education, informing and guiding the “systematic” use of observation as a method for teacher professional development. The cybernetic and systemic thinking, “to understand the totality of factors involved and to intervene in the structural design to achieve more integrated operation” (Tröhler, 2015, p. 756), enabled the observation to be used not only to represent the processes of teaching practice, but also to intervene as a method for more effective operations of teaching. In this use of observation as a process and method of developing teaching through its systematic approach, the future certainty is assumed as predictable and controllable outcomes, which comes into the present through its double gestures (Popkewitz and Lee, in press); the observation diagnoses the differences of teachers in the present, to erase those differences towards the utopic future that every teacher should teach effectively. Observation, as a method for teaching of teaching, becomes self-referential system in that the future of what to see and what kinds of teachers should be made is already inscribed in the present practices of observation. The change and development that the observation as a method promises to achieve cannot be really “new” but self-authorizing in that the problems and solutions of teaching are already inscribed in the systematic observation.
This study begins with the contemporary use of observation rubrics in the U.S. teacher education, drawing the examples from Educator Effectiveness System (state-level teacher evaluation system) and Measures of Effective Teaching (Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation). Then I historicize the reflective teacher education to examine what makes possible the systematic approaches of observation in the making of teachers; particularly, how observation became used to “see” teaching for the reflection of practice and for the development of professionality. This study will expand the discussion on methods to the field of teacher education, by suggesting observation as a method is a historical product, inscribed the (im)possibilities of what to see and what kinds of teachers to be made.