Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Struggling Middle School Readers' Behavioral Engagement in a Self-Directed Supplemental Online Reading Environment

Sat, April 14, 2:15 to 3:45pm, Millennium Broadway New York Times Square, Floor: Seventh Floor, Room 7.02-7.03

Abstract

Purpose: Behaviors and engagement in a literacy learning experience often shape the effectiveness of that experience (Guthrie & Klauda, 2014). This has been consistently demonstrated in remedial literacy interventions where struggling students’ engagement in the intervention contributes to the likelihood of improved outcomes (Kim et al., 2016; Lawrence, Francis, Pare-Blagoev & Snow, 2016). A challenge, however, has been that while remedial reading interventions are increasingly focused on emotional factors, they are often constrained by the sequential, group-administered design of formal curricula and by the limited flexibility inherent in printed materials. We use PROGRAM NAME to push conceptualizations of behavioral engagement in adolescent reading by asking:
1) What characterizes behavioral engagement in an autonomy-driven online literacy environment with varied texts and robust optional supports?
2) Does behavioral engagement in such an environment mediate improvement in reading comprehension for struggling adolescent readers? And,
3) Does the effect of behavioral engagement vary by students’ initial reading comprehension levels?

Theoretical Framework: Motivated readers are engaged readers, readers who are active, involved, and interested (Guthrie & Klauda, 2014). We focus particularly on the construct of behavioral engagement, emphasizing involvement and active participation in available literacy activities, as has been shown to meaningfully contribute to the effectiveness of other literacy interventions (Kim et al., 2016; Taboada, Tonks, Wigfield, & Guthrie, 2009).

Method: This study uses in vivo measurement of engagement within the PROGRAM NAME platform, drawing on students’ choices to use optional features accompanying reading articles as indicators of active involvement (e.g., participating in online discussion, collecting segments to use in projects, indicating emotional responses to the text). Initial reading comprehension was assessed using the RAPID (Lexia Learning, 2016) a standardized, computer-adaptive measure. We use hierarchical linear modeling to account for the nesting of students within classes.

Results: Results indicate that students varied widely in their choices about whether and how to engage in literacy-related activities, with some visiting hundreds of articles and using optional features on virtually all of them, others visiting fewer articles but being very active in engaging with them, and still others reading many articles but not using many of the optional features. Behavioral engagement does not mediate reading comprehension outcomes overall, contrasting with prior findings. But, behavioral engagement has differential effects based on initial reading comprehension. Students who started the year with lower reading comprehension skills benefited more from active engagement with optional features than those starting with relatively higher comprehension skills, even when controlling for a wide range of covariates (Table 1).

Educational Significance: This study extends prior work on behavioral engagement in adolescent literacy by leveraging the autonomy and self-direction in PROGRAM NAME to demonstrate how fully students take advantage of flexibility when available, by using embedded indicators of behavioral engagement to address measurement challenges in prior work, and by including a broad conceptualization of the target population, including any student identified by their middle school as in need of remedial reading support. Results further demonstrate the potential impact of designing to support engagement for the most vulnerable learners.

Authors