Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

"This Is What I Want": Technology Co-Design as a Mirror on Teachers' Science Inquiry Practices

Tue, April 17, 2:15 to 3:45pm, Millennium Broadway New York Times Square, Floor: Seventh Floor, Room 7.04

Abstract

Theoretical Framework. Online science inquiry environments offer opportunities for students to engage with critical science concepts and practices and challenge teachers to find new guidance and orchestration strategies. Teachers must determine who needs help, when, and how, all while moving their students toward shared goals. Drawing on the knowledge integration (KI) framework (Linn & Eylon, 2011), which supports learners’ in building coherence among their various ideas, the Web-based Inquiry Science Environment’s (WISE) teacher tools have been co-designed by a partnership involving teachers, technologists, and researchers. The tools aim to support KI by revealing patterns in students’ ideas that are otherwise difficult to see (Roschelle, Dimitriadis & Hoppe, 2013).
Objectives. Effective tools can empower teachers to adapt, innovate, and skillfully run inquiry-based activities in their classrooms (Biesta & Tedder, 2006; Leary et al., 2016). Such tools gain further relevance when teachers themselves are involved in their design (e.g., Keys & Bryan, 2001; Könings, Seidel & van Merriënboer, 2013). Through co-design, both teachers and researchers come to better understand what each values about inquiry-based teaching and learning, an understanding that is critical to leading and supporting teachers to embrace more effective ways of teaching (e.g., Penuel et al., 2007; Roschelle & Penuel, 2006).
Methods. We articulate insights gained from co-designing teacher tools for WISE (wise.berkeley.edu), an open source, online curriculum platform with free, customizable science units. As WISE has evolved, new student tools that support such practices as reflection, monitoring, modeling, and explanation, allow the system to capture both the processes and products of students’ inquiry. New teacher tools take advantage of logs of student interactions to support teachers’ continuous monitoring and guidance of their students.
Data sources. This poster reports on how 20 teachers, participating in a 4-day professional development workshop, articulated refinements to WISE’s teaching tools. We started with designs based on insights from previous workshops and classroom observations involving these teachers (Matuk et al., 2016). As researchers and developers circulated, the middle and high school science teachers worked in pairs to annotate paper mockups of a grading interface, and to customize their ideal real-time dashboards with paper cutouts.
Results. Participants’ video recorded conversations; designed artifacts; and written responses to reflective prompts, revealed key themes regarding what teachers’ value about inquiry teaching: (1) pacing student progress, such as through setting milestones and tracking progress; (2) noticing students’ improvement (or lack thereof) upon revision after feedback; (3) reducing teachers’ workload, such as by minimizing the amount and sources of information to review; and (4) providing students with just-in-time guidance, such as by seeing and being able to respond to students’ questions. We found that teachers’ design work reflected their different instructional goals, as well as the roles they perceived for technology as an inquiry teaching partner (Gerard, Matuk & Linn, 2016). These revolved around technology-as-time-saver, technology-as-informant, and technology-as-power in navigating shifting dynamics between themselves and their students, sometimes yielding control to students, and sometimes enabling teachers to maintain and enact control.
Significance. The insights teachers contributed underscore the value of co-design for understanding and supporting KI.

Authors