Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Interpreting Motivational Roadblocks: Attributions to Interest as a Function of Gender and Domain

Mon, April 16, 10:35am to 12:05pm, Millennium Broadway New York Times Square, Floor: Fifth Floor, Room 5.08

Abstract

Objectives
One key to students’ motivation regulation may lie in how they interpret motivational roadblocks. The current research begins to examine these interpretations as a function of domain and gender.

Theoretical significance
The experience of interest has been proposed as integral to maintaining motivation over time (Sansone & Thoman, 2005), but how students respond to lack of interest depends on their implicit theories about how motivation works. Thoman, Sansone, and Robinson (2017) found that students who believed that interest in an activity could be changed were more likely to report having used interest-enhancing strategies than students who believed that experiences of interest were stable. These findings suggest that metamotivational beliefs about the malleability of interest can influence whether and when students regulate their interest. The current research examined students’ beliefs about why they experience motivational roadblocks in the first place, comparing the extent to which students attributed a particular roadblock to lack of interest in the activity versus the domain, and to lack of ability versus effort. In addition, we examined whether these beliefs are sensitive to characteristics of the person (gender) and the domain (STEM v. non-STEM).

Methods
Female (N=409) and male (N=159) undergraduates were recruited from two state universities to participate in a study about providing online advice to advanced high school students. They were assigned to one of 4 conditions in a 2 (target gender: male v. female) by 2 (domain: history v. physics) design. They were provided the case of “Jordan” (which included a photo of a Caucasian male or female) who was having trouble getting started on his/her history/physics project. After the description, participants were asked to rate (7 point scales) how much each of seven possible causes were responsible for Jordan’s motivational difficulties (project difficulty; project irrelevance; project uninteresting; domain uninteresting; lack of ability; lack of effort; lack of self-discipline). They also indicated how many history and physics courses they had taken (included as covariates).

Results
Separate 2 x 2 MANOVAs were performed on attribution ratings for male and female subsamples. Male participants were more likely to attribute Jordan’s problem to the project being uninteresting and irrelevant when Jordan was male, and to lack of ability and domain uninterestingness when Jordan was female doing physics or male doing history (Fs (1, 153) = 3.77-5.87, ps = .05-.02). In contrast, female participants were more likely to attribute Jordan’s problem in physics to project difficulty and domain uninterestingness, regardless of Jordan’s gender (Fs (1, 403) = 5.89-12.85, ps = .02-.00).

Significance
Male and female undergraduates had beliefs about the causes of motivational roadblocks that were differentially sensitive to gender and domain. Both appeared to interpret Jordan’s problem as less amenable to regulation when it involved a female in physics (e.g., lack of domain interest). When Jordan was male, males were more likely to see his problem as pertaining to the project rather than the domain. These differences have important implications for students’ own motivation regulation as well as for the feedback they provide peers.

Authors