Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Family Needs Matter: Chinese Parents' Choice of Whole-Day Versus Half-Day Kindergarten Program

Tue, April 9, 10:25 to 11:55am, Metro Toronto Convention Centre, Floor: 600 Level, Room 601A

Abstract

Many governments offer citizens free early childhood education (ECE) but only for limited hours per week. Following the global trend, the Hong Kong government also launched the unprecedented Free Quality Kindergarten Education Scheme to offer kindergarten education to children aged 3 to 6 but this free service is only limited to half-day program (3 hours/day) attendees; whole-day program (7.5 hours/day) attendees are to bear the excess burden. The public criticized the policy for underestimating the educational impact of the whole-day program and disregarding the societal need for it given women’s increasing workforce participation. Responding to this complicated social-educational issue, this territory-wide study adopted the Donabedian structure-process-outcome approach to explore the perceptions of parents on the impact of whole-day versus half-day program on children’s development.

This study surveyed 307 parents (57 fathers, 250 mothers) of 3-year-old first-year kindergarteners from 15 randomly sampled local kindergartens that offered both programs simultaneously. The questionnaire asked for the parents’ demographic information and their views on the two programs via quantitative and qualitative responses.

The two parent cohorts did not differ significantly in age, family income, or academic qualifications. Their child’s program attendance (whole-day or half-day) was found to be significantly related to their program preference; t(302)=418.51, p<0.001. 95.6% of the whole-day parents supported the whole-day program, but only 60% of the half-day parents supported the half-day program as 39.31% of them supported the whole-day program. Altogether, 68.75% supported the whole-day program, 30.59% supported the half-day program, while 0.66% opted for both (see Figure 1 for parents’ support across various areas). The whole-day program demonstrated structural benefits in incorporating an all-round curricular content where academic and non-academic skills (e.g., self-care and independence) as well as discipline and a structured lifestyle were cultivated in children. Children were believed to enjoy a relaxed learning environment and more professional support. Parents were excused from the childcare pressure and could work full-time. Teachers and kindergartens enjoyed efficiency in educational operation and resource utilization. See Table 1 for the two programs’ strengths.

Children’s program attendance was significantly related to parents’ support for the universalization of the whole-day program; t(298)=8.08, p=.005. Altogether, only 37% agreed, 8.67% disagreed, 12.67% suggested both programs should remain, while 41.67% could not make a decision. Qualitative responses indicated that parents experienced a dilemma –– 1) safeguarding the Confucian beliefs of academic achievement (perceived strength of the whole-day program) versus parents’ responsibility to provide children a happy childhood (perceived strength of the half-day program); 2) earning for the family while leaving children under the care of domestic helpers or grandparents versus spending quality time and building a strong relationship with them. Two practical concerns were found: mothers’ job engagement and preparation for children’s school readiness for future primary schooling.

The authors regard that both programs should remain as no single program could fit all families –– program selection should reflect family needs and interests. The government should increase whole-day places (currently under-supply) and ensure families’ equal access to them to allow for female workforce participation.

Authors