Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Post-Truth, Truthiness, and Obfuscation: DisCrit Solidarity and the Multiple Truths of Dis/ability Identification

Sat, April 6, 12:20 to 1:50pm, Metro Toronto Convention Centre, Floor: 700 Level, Room 715B

Abstract

Objectives or purposes
In this paper we undertake an historical analysis of the influences of racism and ableism in shaping the allocation of educational opportunities and resources to Asian American students within the United States.

Perspective(s) or theoretical framework
Our design and analysis are informed by Disability Critical Race Theory (DisCrit) (Annamma, Connor and Ferri, 2013; Annamma, Connor and Ferri, 2018) and further informed by DisCrit Solidarity (Annamma & Morrison, 2018). Drawing from these frameworks, we understand disability identifications as historically, culturally and interpersonally situated and intersected with similarly situated identifications of race and ethnicity.
In the United States, immigrant and minority populations’ “worth” and potential worthiness as future citizens have been regularly measured by a yardstick that reflects the intersecting interests of capitalism, racism, and ableism. Immigrants and potential immigrants are judged on the likelihood that they will become a strain on state resources, and identifications of race, ethnicity, and dis/ability have been used to mark and exclude minoritized populations from full access to resources and modes of participation (Baynton, 2001; Dolmage, 2011; Schweik, 2009; Wu, 2013).
Prior to World War II, Asian immigrants and Asian Americans were marked as “definitively not white” (Wu, 2013, p. 2) and subjected to legal, political, economic and social exclusion. By the mid-1960’s, due largely to capitalistic interests, Asian American were re-positioned as “the model minority--a racial group distinct from the white majority, but lauded as well-assimilated, upwardly mobile, politically nonthreatening, and definitively not-black” (Wu, 2013, p. 2).
The experiences of Asian and Asian American students provide an illustrative case for understanding the workings of racism, ableism, and capitalism in shaping dis/ability identification. We intentionally trouble and extend the current academic conversations around race and dis/ability identification, a conversation, which has all but excluded the experiences of Asian American students (Kozleski, 2016; Lee, 2009).

Methods
We undertake an historical analysis of the influences of racism and ableism in shaping the allocation of educational opportunities and resources to Asian American students through narrative and discourse analysis of historical texts and artifacts. Additionally, we connect this cultural-historical analysis to the individual and personal experiences of the first author and her family through auto ethnography, discourse analysis, extensive interviews and content analysis of documents.

Results
By foregrounding the experiences of Asian Americans as an illustrative case, our work illustrates the interdependence of racism, ableism and capitalism within the cultural storylines used to identify and locate dis/ability. We advance the notion of cultural camouflage as a way of understanding how these culturally situated storylines shape teachers’ interpretation of Asian American students’ discourse, actions, appearance and efforts. Further, we trace the influence of these storylines on the academic conversations around under- and over- representation.
Significance
Our study complicates and extends current discussions of underrepresentation with consideration of the historical, cultural and interactional aspects of dis/ability identification.

Authors