Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Exploring the Relationship Between Quality Practice and Youth Leadership Outcomes in New York City

Sun, April 7, 11:50am to 1:20pm, Sheraton Centre Toronto Hotel, Floor: Second Floor, Kenora

Abstract

Objectives or purposes

This multiyear, mixed-methods evaluation explores implementation and outcomes of the School’s Out New York City (SONYC) initiative. The goals are to help build the knowledge base in out-of-school time (OST) and to understand the influence of high-quality program implementation on youth outcomes. The evaluation (in its fifth year) answers three questions about how programs are implemented, stakeholder perceptions, and relationships between program practices and youth leadership development (YLD).

Perspective(s) or theoretical framework

The NYC Department of Youth and Community Development (DYCD) Comprehensive After School System of New York City (COMPASS NYC) comprises more than 900 programs serving young people enrolled in Grades K–12. COMPASS NYC offers programs with academics, recreation, enrichment, and cultural activities to support youth developmnet. The COMPASS NYC middle school model, better known as SONYC offers youth choice; and provides rigorous instruction in academics and youth development.
Methods, techniques, or modes of inquiry / Data sources, evidence, objects, or materials
In Year 1, we conducted a data scan and case study of 38 exemplary programs to describe the implementation of practices in SONYC programs including interview, observations and surveys.
Findings from the first year of the evaluation led us to focus on YLD as the outcome of interest. In Year 2, we piloted a youth survey to understand youth perspectives skills related to YLD. In Year 3, we administered the survey in a representative sample of programs. Findings indicate that the reliability of the scores for the main constructs were within acceptable ranges, survey items fit the rating scale model, and rating scales functioned well.
In Year 4 (2017-18), we engaged a representative sample of 100 programs to examine the relation between quality youth development practices that support leadership and outcomes on the YLD survey. We used the Social and Emotional Learning (SEL) Program Quality Assessment to conduct on-site observations and administered the YLD survey to youth who had active parental consent. We also interviewed directors regarding the supports for and implementation of practices that support YLD.

Results and/or substantiated conclusions or warrants for arguments/point of view

Findings suggest stakeholders have positive perceptions of SONYC programs.
• Principals and program directors report positive perception of the program design and delivery, especially with respect to the climate and culture The majority of principals and programs directors agreed that the SONYC program contributies to improvements in in- and out-of-school outcomes
• The SONYC program provides opportunities for youth to develop leadership attitudes and skills.
• Youth report high perceptions of their leadership attitudes and skills, with the most favorable responses in motivation, self-awareness, and persistence).

Scientific or scholarly significance of the study or work

Stakeholders have positive perceptions of the program and that youth report positive perceptions of their leadership attitudes and skills. Findings from Year 4 of the SONYC evaluation shed light on the most commonly employed practices that support youth leadership and explain whether and how quality opportunities for YLD support youth perceptions of their own abilities.

Author