Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Leveraging Research to Advance Countercultural Pedagogical Work in Mexico and Colombia

Sun, April 7, 8:00 to 9:30am, Metro Toronto Convention Centre, Floor: 200 Level, Room 205B

Abstract

Purpose

This presentation discusses how and under what conditions counter-hegemonic pedagogies can spread to thousands of schools, using the Learning Community Project (LCP) in Mexico and Escuela Nueva (EN) in Colombia as case studies. It discusses how educational research can be leveraged to advance countercultural work in schools and school systems.

Initiated as grassroots pedagogical change projects in remote rural communities, LCP and EN turned into national policies that transformed pedagogy in thousands of public schools, improving student achievement at a faster pace than, and surpassing, schools in more privileged contexts (McEwan, 1998; Psachoropoulos, Rojas & Velez, 1992; Rincón-Gallardo, 2016).

Perspective

Large-scale pedagogical transformation is conceptualized herein as wide-spread cultural change (Rochon, 1998), a process that occurs when counterhegemonic values and practices developed by a critical community are taken up by movements that spread these in three arenas: the pedagogical, the social, and the political arenas. In the spirit of Santos’ (2014) Epistemologies of the South and Lather’s (1988) Research as Praxis, research is conceptualized here as an act of solidarity to advance (educational) justice alongside those historically oppressed and marginalized.

Methods and Data Sources

Two in-depth case studies were created to capture the history and development of LCP and EN from their origins to 2015. The case studies drew from rich sources of data consisting of interviews and focus groups with 127 actors, classroom observations in 20 schools, and over 800 documents. Data was reviewed with the explicit intention of identifying core principles of action in common between LCP and EN, as well as key shortcomings.

In order to examine whether and how research was leveraged to advance educational justice through LCP and EN, reflective memos written during the research process, as well as email communications and notes of conversations with interviewees, were collected and reviewed.

Substantiated Conclusions

An examination of the research process to create and mobilize knowledge for and about the widespread dissemination of countercultural pedagogies in Mexico and Colombia offers some principles of action to leverage research for educational justice:
a. Articulate and communicate the implicit theory of action underlying the countercultural work undertaken by movement participants.
b. Identify “blind-spots” and core areas of improvement internal to the pedagogical change work, and work with movement participants to jointly identify ways to address them.
c. Identify institutional practices, structures and systems that constrain the efforts of educators and school and system leaders to fundamentally transform teaching and learning.
d. Mobilize evidence of impact and institutional constraints to changes what gets in the way of effective pedagogical practice.
e. Amplify the visibility of effective pedagogical change movements to attract local and international supporters and allies.

Scholarly significance

This presentation articulates five principles of action to leverage research to advance countercultural work in schools and classrooms. It also brings visibility to successful examples of widespread pedagogical change from the Global South. This represents an important contribution to the knowledge base required to turn educational research into an effective vehicle to democratize evidence and advance educational justice.

Author