Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Students' Visualized Perceptions About Importance at School

Mon, April 8, 2:15 to 3:45pm, Sheraton Centre Toronto Hotel, Floor: Second Floor, Wentworth

Abstract

Like others who work from multiliteracies perspectives, this research capitalizes on expanding definitions of literacy to include visual and multimodal texts for communication. Broader definitions of literacy are critically important in our overwhelmingly visual societies where images are consistently in view and easily accessible. Educators can “no longer treat reading as being solely about print... Rather, we need to address a full range of modalities being used by young people” (Stone, 2007, p.60).
By capitalizing on the visual nature of contemporary society for instruction, schools provide alternate and perhaps more accommodating and flexible pathways to access and express curricular understandings for all students (Ranker, 2014). Multimodal texts can be used to demonstrate knowledge where language does not limit cognition (Eisner, 2002). In this way, a multiliteracies approach has the potential to become an essential and equitable instructional practice. This is especially significant when tackling complex and abstract ideas such as importance which is at the core of this study. Students read, discussed, and wrote about the idea of importance and then illustrated what was important about their school. The purpose of this research is to explore the ways sixth graders at one elementary school near the United States/Mexico border used multimodal texts (drawings and photography) to articulate their perceptions.
This study expands on multimodal methods that utilizes images for educational research, especially how visual modes provide access to students’ perceptions. Following Bintz (1997) and Kaplan and Howes (2004) who offered students cameras as tools for expressing perceptions about their school study sites, I offered 90 sixth-grader writers (67% labeled English learners) at Frontera Elementary School (pseudonym) cameras and markers to illustrate perceptions of importance at their school. I chose multimodal communication methods because they have the potential to “level the playing field” (Holloway, 2012) for the English learners in our classroom, fostering equity and providing opportunities for all students to participate equally.
The data set includes 180 multimodal texts created by sixth graders during one month near the middle of the academic year. I used critical visual content analysis to consider ways students might challenge dominant messaging about school. Findings reveal many images of privileged education discourses, depicting traditionally valued ideas of importance including themes of relationships (friends and teachers), resources (books and technology) and play. However, students’ conceptualizations of importance also represent competing voices in the mulitmodal texts. Students also created compositions that challenging gender, community and relationships, as well as display less academically valued learning such as gardening.
Images were valuable tools for student writers to convey their ideas about school in this participatory research. They expressed both traditionally valued ideas as well as counternarratives of what is recognized as important. Visual texts provided an alternate communication tool, one not limited by traditional school norms; one that can be used by all students regardless of their literacy and language skills. Thus, visual texts for demonstration of knowledge as well as for highlighting student perceptions has the potential to be equitable practice for pedagogy and in research.

Author