Search
Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Room
Browse By Unit
Browse By Session Type
Search Tips
Annual Meeting Registraion, Housing and Travel
Personal Schedule
Sign In
This paper explores post-truth in relation to the representation of space. Specifically, I discuss critical and creative cartography (CCC)—the practice of creating maps as resistance to hegemonic notions of space—as a tool for learning about how maps make and represent reality (Crampton & Krygier, 2005). I draw on examples of historical maps and critical and creative cartographers in contemporary art to conceptualize this tool, and then discuss findings from my doctoral research on CCC in high school art classes to suggest ways of applying this tool in educational contexts.
Examining historical maps highlights that representing space is rooted in basic cultural assumptions that shape our conceptualization of space and that these concepts have consequences. For example, 16th century maps of the Aztec and Spanish revealed their different perceptions of space and foretold the historical outcomes of their encounter (Massey, 2005). Western representation of space implicitly “equates space with the land and sea,” and conceives of “other places, peoples, [and] cultures simply as phenomena ‘on’ this surface” (Massey, 2005, p. 4). This view of space has played a key role in validating the conquests of the colonial era and still permeates today.
More recently, artists have constructed maps to resist colonial and other hegemonic notions. Their creative and critical practices assume that maps construct knowledge, exercise power, and oppose “received notions of space, knowledge and power” (Crampton & Krygier, 2005, p. 25). Several artists use maps to bring awareness to the personal, interpersonal, and the socio-political structures that constitute a space (e.g., Debord, 1958; Thompson, 2008). These examples provide models for how art educators can teach students about multiple accounts of space and the structures implicated in spatial representations.
In my research, I developed a curricular intervention that incorporates CCC into high school art classrooms in Montreal, Canada. I used design-based research, an interventionist methodology used by educational researchers to develop systematic yet flexible design principles and theories that are tested in real-world settings (Barab & Squire, 2004). My research involved designing a curricular intervention and testing it by conducting workshops in two high school art classes in collaboration with two art teachers. Activities included discussions of maps as constructions of reality and creating a collective map of the neighborhoods where students live. I collected qualitative data, including interviews with students and teachers, student photographs and collective maps.
My intervention showed that CCC informed the students that the spaces of their daily lives could be represented from multiple perspectives and shaped by various social and political factors. Framed with the examples of historical maps and artistic map-making noted above, I conclude that this intervention can address post-truth with students by highlighting the relation of power to claims of truth in mapmaking, and by using online maps as a tool to explore and represent the multiplicity of everyday spaces. The skills of critically examining maps and images, and contributing to online maps, are important components of digital citizenship in the age of post-truth.