Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

How the Structure and Demands of Student Affairs Reflect Ideal Worker Norms and Influence Work-Life Integration

Sun, April 19, 12:25 to 1:55pm, Virtual Room

Abstract

Objectives
Student affairs has historically lent itself to someone who can prioritize job duties over personal responsibilities. This paper explores the demands of the student affairs profession, how the culture of the profession is shaped and perpetuated by ideal worker norms, and how ideal worker norms create conflict for work-life integration goals. Student affairs work, and the context in which it occurs, needs to evolve away from ideal worker norms towards a more “life-friendly” orientation to accomplish the goals of facilitating student success. Such an evolution will require cultural shifts that begin with how we treat student paraprofessionals, graduate students, new professionals, those in mid-career, as well as those at the highest levels of the profession.
Theoretical Framework
When the nature of a job requires an employee to be able to put work first, both during scheduled work hours, as well as after hours, ideal worker norms are perpetuated (Bailyn, 1993; Davies & Frink, 2014; Kelly, et al., 2008). The concept of an “ideal worker” was constructed around gendered roles, where the only, or primary, responsibility of the ideal worker was paid work. This means the employee is available and ready to work at the will of the employer and either has no family obligations or has a spouse to assume those responsibilities (Hochschild, 1995; Sallee, 2016; Williams, 2000).
Results
Due to space limitations, only a handful of conclusions are highlighted below.
• Failure to recognize student affairs professionals in their multiple roles both inside and outside the institution stands in contrast to the field’s commitment to recognize the “whole student.”
• Socialization into student affairs starts early and is continuously reinforced at various levels by peers, supervisors, and chief student affairs officers.
• What it means to be a successful student affairs professional is rooted in the culture of the profession, which is influenced by the formal structures and informal practices within the workplace.
• Cultural norms about what it means to be a successful student affairs professional vary across institutions, departments, and even among positions. Nonetheless, ideal worker norms prevail.
Significance
There are both individual as well as institutional costs that come with expecting that student affairs professionals engage in all-consuming work patterns. When individuals perceive that there are not enough hours in the day to accomplish both work-and home-related obligations, they may experience negative effects in terms of their ability to do their work, career satisfaction and/or personal well-being (Cameron, 2011; Chessman, 2018; Isdell, 2016).
This paper provides concrete advice for ways that student affairs professionals can alter their practices in order to change the culture. The paper also recognizes the role that the profession and institutions of higher education play in perpetuating ideal worker norms and offers practical policies and advice on ways to address these concerns institutionally for individuals throughout the career span – from graduate student to senior student affairs professional.

Authors