Search
Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Unit
Browse By Session Type
Search Tips
Annual Meeting Housing and Travel
Personal Schedule
Sign In
X (Twitter)
Public schools today remain highly segregated both by race and class, as the desegregation efforts of the late 1960s and early 1970s did not last. Several studies of the effects of the desegregation of Southern school districts in the 1960s and 1970s demonstrate that desegregation 1) expanded access to school resources for black students; 2) improved educational and long-term adult outcomes for black students; and 3) had no negative impact on white students (Ashenfelter, Collins, & Yoon, 2006; Guryan, 2004; Johnson, 2011). If desegregation improved educational outcomes for black students through changing their school resource contexts, what is the effect of contemporary segregation on educational outcomes?
In this paper, we ask: Does contemporary segregation lead to unequal educational opportunity and outcomes? We examine the association between school segregation patterns and the size and growth of academic achievement gaps in every school district, county, and metropolitan area in the U.S., using data from grades 3-8 and from 2009-2016. Our analysis is the first to examine the effect of contemporary segregation across time, place, and multiple measures of educational inequality and has broad and important implications for education policy.
The achievement data come from the Stanford Education Data Archive (Version 3.0), which includes nationally normed academic achievement from state accountability reading and mathematics tests for the universe of public school districts in the U.S. We use the mean test scores for white, black, and Hispanic students. We generate our segregation measures (e.g. racial differences in exposure to minority and poor schoolmates) and covariates using data from the Common Core of Data, the American Community Survey, and EDFacts.
We use both cross-sectional multi-level models and fixed-effects panel models to estimate the associations between segregation and both achievement gaps and the rate at which the gaps change as children progress through school (e.g. changes in the gap from 5th grade in 2010 to sixth grade in 2011). We fit all models separately at each aggregation (i.e. district, county, and metro) and for each outcome measure (white-black and white-Hispanic achievement gaps).
Across districts and counties, racial differences in exposure to poor schoolmates is positively related to both the size and growth of white-black and white-Hispanic achievement gaps. Racial differences in exposure to minority schoolmates is negatively associated with the size of the white-black achievement gap. Results from our panel models provide evidence that racial differences in exposure to poor schoolmates is positively associated with white-black and white-Hispanic achievement gaps in districts and counties. See our cross-sectional and panel models in Tables P3.1 and P3.2.
Taken together, our findings provide robust evidence that racial differences in exposure to poverty exacerbate educational opportunity. This is particularly true across districts and counties in both cross-sectional and panel models. While not robust, the significant and negative finding for racial differences in exposure to minority schoolmates and white-black gaps is noteworthy. This finding suggests that if black students are in predominately black middle-class schools, they have better achievement outcomes than if they were in middle class schools with white students.
Sean F. Reardon, Stanford University
Ericka S. Weathers, The Pennsylvania State University
Demetra Kalogrides, Stanford University
Heewon Jang, Stanford University
Erin Michelle Fahle, St. John's University