Search
Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Unit
Browse By Session Type
Search Tips
Annual Meeting Housing and Travel
Personal Schedule
Sign In
X (Twitter)
Objectives
This paper examines a three-year partnership between a university-based literacy researcher and community organization providing culturally-based health and educational services to a multi-tribal American Indian population in central California. Specifically, this paper explores how norms and processes were established and how they evolved and how power and identity were explicitly foregrounded and continually negotiated. An argument is extended for designing and engaging in forms of participatory research that are particularly attentive to local knowledge and organizational structures.
Theoretical Framework
Presenter 2 problematizes the relationship between academic knowledge and lived experience, asking: how might academic knowledge (in the form of theoretical frameworks, for instance) crowd out other forms of knowledge? Even with “the assumption of equality as the starting point” among all stakeholders (Campano, Ghiso, & Welch, 2015, p. 37), and even when “specific research foci and questions are codesigned with community members” (p. 40), academic knowledge – rendered in language that is often inscrutable – is afforded sufficient symbolic capital to disproportionately dictate norms, processes, and initiatives.
Data Sources/Methods
Presenter 2 (re)constructs his experiences co-constructing a university-community partnership using fieldnotes and analytic memos composed during three years of collaboration. He analyzes these data using autoethnographic methods (Ellis, Adams, & Bochner, 2011) – focusing on knowledge, power, and identity – and presents findings as storytelling vignettes (e.g., Richardson, 1997). The goal is to “develop an antagonism in myself, to step back and examine my interpretive frames and presentations” (Hesford, 1999, p. xxxiii). These vignettes include examinations of Presenter 2's enthusiasm for dialogic collaboration, and how it "might be an unwitting imperialist demand" (Jones & Jenkins, 2008).
Findings/Significance
Academicians’ ethical stances run the risk of reinscribing power differentials (Corrigan, 2000) even as reciprocity and horizontal processes are deliberately foregrounded. Presenter 2, a non-Indigenous researcher, began partnering with an American Indian-serving organization having read extensively about decolonizing methodologies (Smith, 2012), Indigenous methodologies (Kovach, 2009; Wilson, 2008), and damage-decentered research (Tuck, 2009b). Organizational leaders possessed significant experience generating critical operational theories (Moya, 2002) but were not familiar with these readings – and admitted to feeling “awed” by them. Within an environment that is frequently hostile to Native people, these leaders built an organization offering culturally-responsive behavioral health services in addition to youth programming and community restoration initiatives. Regardless of whether they identified as theorists, their work was dependent on numerous theories, including postcoloniality and the Gadamerian dialectic of “what is” and “what could be” (1989).
We entered our partnership with numerous questions. Whose knowledge and experience would be salient? How would we negotiate our various forms of knowledge capital? Who would determine the “real-world problems” to be addressed within the local milieu, where identified problems ranged from children’s reading comprehension and nutritional needs to linguistic and cultural erasure? How would methodologies be determined, data collected, findings reported? Paper 2 explores these significant questions of community-based research, paying particular attention to knowledge, power, and identity.