Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Systems That Work: Evidence From Highly Effective Large-Scale Literacy Programs in Low- and Middle-Income Countries

Mon, April 25, 4:15 to 5:45pm PDT (4:15 to 5:45pm PDT), Division Virtual Rooms, Division L - Section 9: Policy Implementation and Going to Scale Virtual Paper Session Room

Abstract

Literacy outcomes in low- and middle-income countries are very low. Increased attention to this problem has resulted in a growing number of small- or medium-scale interventions around the world that have shown success in improving outcomes. Yet, very few programs have successfully attempted to improve learning outcomes at large scale. As a result, evidence is limited as to what characteristics differentiate the successful interventions at scale from the many that have not been able to improve outcomes. This is because learning outcomes are difficult to improve and because few programs have been focused on the actual system requirements of effective implementation at large scale. To address this gap, the Learning at Scale study, funded by the Gates Foundation—the study on which our proposed presentation will report—investigated the system components of eight successful large-scale early literacy programs operating in low and lower-middle income countries. These programs were selected because of their rigorous evidence of impact and implementation on a large or national scale. The study answered the following research question: What system support is required to deliver effective training and support to teachers and to promote effective classroom practices? The large-scale, highly effective programs studied were implemented in tens of thousands of schools in Ghana, India (two programs), Kenya, Nigeria, Pakistan, Senegal and Tanzania.

The data we collected included qualitative interviews at the district, subnational, national, funding agency and implementing partner levels. Our analysis focused on understanding causal relationships between particular program elements and program impact. While the contexts were different, the findings suggest some patterns in how these programs worked with their respective systems. For example, we found that programs achieved success when their activities and objectives were seen as important priorities to education system leaders and officials. Program success was also in part dependent on those education system stakeholders systematically communicating that priority down the system, establishing clear expectations for student level outcomes as well as for changed practice on the part of teachers and district and sub-district officials.

The success of these interventions depended largely on helping lower levels of the system to effectively interact with schools with an increased emphasis on learning outcomes and program implementation. One interpretation of the Learning at Scale systems findings was that these programs were successful because they were able to work at the system level to support organizational and cultural changes of teaching and learning up and down the system. Additionally, successful at-scale programs invested in building key government capacities (i.e., curriculum implementation) and supported a gradual transfer of program responsibility to the education system structures and staff.

These findings—that will be discussed in detail in the presentation—inform recommendations for large-scale implementation and ways to differentiate future large-scale programs in their ability to effectively work with and through government systems. The findings are essential to inform low- and middle-income countries’ attempts to improve literacy outcomes at large scale.

Author