Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Logical Limitations of Mathematical and Abstract Modeling Approaches to Top-Down Educational Reform

Tue, April 26, 4:15 to 5:45pm PDT (4:15 to 5:45pm PDT), World Educational Research Association Virtual Meeting Rooms, WERA Virtual Meeting Room 1

Abstract

Abstract:
This paper seeks to explain the mathematical and logical limits to policy modeling. In particular, it is suggested that mathematically vigorous, predictive models of social behavior and policy implementation are highly susceptible to unintended consequences, serious evaluation problems and policy failure. The fundamental logical and mathematical issues are explored through the modeling critique of Tomas Aquinas, mathematical chaos theory and the philosophical problems in bridging idealisms and observable reality. Further, economist Charles Goodhart’s “law” is consulted in order to demonstrate evaluation problems common in top-down reform efforts. Finally, a cyclical model of policy implementation is suggested for more effective reform.

Author