Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

The Potential of Educator Supervision and Evaluation to Transform Schools Into Complex Adaptive Systems

Sat, April 15, 2:50 to 4:20pm CDT (2:50 to 4:20pm CDT), Sheraton Grand Chicago Riverwalk, Floor: Level 2, Colorado

Abstract

Summary

The proposed paper aims to reveal how educator supervision and evaluation, when undertaken by administrators with the principles of Complexity Theory in mind, have considerable potential to help schools move from being merely complex systems to complex adaptive ones – ones in which educators take well-considered instructional risks with ongoing support from administrators and colleagues.


Theoretical Framework

Complexity Theory attends to the continuously emerging interrelationships between agents within complex adaptive systems. Unlike mechanistic systems, complex adaptive systems are dynamic. Not only do relationships between agents within systems change over time, but agents themselves evolve, as do systems’ relationships with their environments.

Connection to the Literature

With their dual – and, some argue, conflicting – functions of supporting educators’ professional growth while assessing their performance, supervision and evaluation have long been the focus of scholars, and – since the early 2000s – the subjects of increased policymaking. Intended collectively to enhance educators’ skill at engaging students in meaningful learning experiences, to improve school performance, and to advance the education enterprise overall, educator supervision and evaluation have historically fallen short of these goals.

A theoretical analysis of the concepts being discussed

Much has been written about the perceived intractable tension between supervision and evaluation. The aim of the proposed paper is to demonstrate that this tension – when approached through the lens of Complexity Theory – should be seen, not as a constraint, but as a point of criticality.

By frequenting classrooms (rather than limiting their visits to formal observations); by regularly engaging educators in candid discussions about their instructional practices (rather than limiting such conversations to summative evaluation conferences, or leaving them to be facilitated by instructional coaches); and by fostering cultures in which educators commonly observe, provide feedback to, and learn from one another (rather than function in isolation), administrators prime their schools for emergent learning and improvement.

Davies (2016) writes, “education systems will not get to the edge of chaos any time soon” (p. 35). I contend that if administrators – informed by Complexity Theory – recognize the generative potential of their dual roles, rather than shy away from them, their execution of those functions will be perturbative, altering how educators – as system elements – routinely interact, and inspiring their instructional creativity. In short, they will be “creating the conditions that will create the conditions” that contribute to better learning experiences for students (McQuillan, 2020, p. 97).

Contribution to the field or significance of the work

The proposed paper will reconceptualize supervision and evaluation’s functions, from being in apparent conflict, to being complementary. In so doing, it will reveal their generative potential to transform schools from merely complex systems (in which educators work in isolation, with only incidental improvement) to complex adaptive ones (in which instruction is regularly observed, and educators – including administrators – provide feedback to one another on an ongoing basis). It will inspire, to borrow Sands et al.’s (2022) phrase, “continuous learning fostered through regular exchange between individuals” (p. 25).

Author