Search
On-Site Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Room
Browse By Unit
Browse By Session Type
About AERA 2023 Annual Meeting
Program Information
Key Dates / FAQ
Search Tips
Change Preferences / Time Zone
Sign In
The purpose of this paper is to describe a discussion strategy that is designed to center the “affective politics” (Nash, 2013) of anti-racist work in our current times. In contrast to discussion strategies that center rational deliberation or attend to identity politics, we engaged a group of practicing social studies teachers in a discussion that invited an experience centered on shared affective and emotional registers related to anti-racist work.
The paper is framed by Black feminist scholar Jennifer C Nash’s (2013) notion of “affective politics”, which explores experiences of feeling states and their relationship to potentials for political movement. This stands in contrast to identity politics due to its “at-times problematic elisions and lapses into essentialism” (p. 2). The focus on affective politics recognizes the limits of the liberal focus on the individual and offers a circuit for theorizing beyond the individual and within the unfolding historical present as lived in community.
The two authors of the paper (one a Black woman, one a white man) and nine practicing social studies teachers participated in a focus-group/dialogue session structured around prompts intended to invite shared experiences of what it means to participate in anti-racist work. One prompt was for each participant to share a story from their anti-racist work that was accompanied by some form of hesitancy.
Through their personal narratives related to their experiences in teaching towards anti-racist education participants reflected on hesitations related to how they would be perceived. As expected participants expressed different hesitations and perceptions of risks related to anti-racist work that were largely shaped by their racial identity, lived experiences, and personal dispositions. The transcribed focus-group discussion as well as the authors’ notes and reflection serve as the data from which we make our arguments and illustrate the structures of this discussion strategy. Through our analysis of the data, we identified several patterns that we organized as themes (Bhattacharya, 2017). For the purpose of this proposal, we focus on one of these themes, identified as: The authoritarian white super ego. An unspoken internalized authority was related to inhibitions in teachers’ anti-racist work, and this authority was often a worry about the ways white people would respond or perceive their actions. For instance, one Black male teacher desired to teach his majority Black students a critical history through an African-American history course, but recounted withholding because of the presence of one white student. A few white teachers recalled worrying about parental complaints, yet these anticipated parental complaints were from parents of white students, and never about the parents of Black students.
We explore the phenomenon of this internalized white authority, but also focus on the process by which these stories were elicited. We feel that discussions that center and invite participants’ lived experiences can support anti-racist work and challenge anti-Blackness. We contend that work centered on affective politics illuminates the lived consequences of anti-blackness, attends to the facts of consequences, and makes space for the possibilities for new experiences of connection and belonging.