Search
On-Site Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Room
Browse By Unit
Browse By Session Type
About AERA 2023 Annual Meeting
Program Information
Key Dates / FAQ
Search Tips
Change Preferences / Time Zone
Sign In
Objectives
By redefining the Journey Box (Labbo & Field, 1999) through critical historical inquiry (Salinas, & Blevins, 2014), our elementary bilingual teacher education social studies methods course has developed stronger culturally and linguistically relevant narratives. As a means of disruption (pedagogies), the narratives embody often neglected portraits of the civic identity, agency and membership of the Latine community.
Perspectives
The enactment of critical historical inquiry, through a journey box assignment (a student authored/curated collection of primary sources, document-based questions, and narrative about a person/event) is framed by critical pedagogy (Blevins, et al., 2015), sociocultural narrative work (Wertsch, 1998) and cultural citizenship (Rosaldo, 1997). The journey box assignment provides social studies educators with opportunities to examine how counter-narratives can provide invaluable civic spaces for Latine bilingual teachers and their students (Salinas, et al., 2012, 2015).
The disruption of dominant narratives requires political/ideological clarity (Bartolomé, 1994), i.e., an understanding that the official school curriculum sustains a dominant state of power, excluding marginalized communities. For students of color, including other narratives reveals how culture (race, class, gender, sexuality) is inherently part of citizenship. The “mark” of citizenship for Latine communities is incomplete through traditional citizenship education models (e.g. Westheimer & Kahne, 2004), but through cultural citizenship are sources of resistance that cultivate civic participation for Latine communities (e.g. Jaffee, 2016). Cultural citizenship posits that understanding that social practices, such as protestas, pláticas, and teatro, are crucial in reconceptualizing civic education. In these spaces the Latine community are “claiming rights, what is their own, (and) defending it” (Flores & Benmayor, 1998, p. 13) as their whole selves.
Methods
This ongoing qualitative case study in an elementary bilingual social studies methods course examines how Latine bilingual teachers identify erroneous narratives in the social studies. The cohort of Latine bilingual teacher education candidates (n=15 each spring 2020, 2021, 2022) are introduced to journey box/critical historical exemplars (e.g. Emma Tenayuca) to examine the narratives by which Latine have sought to assert their civicness. In selecting their narratives, students trouble the dominant narrative and develop a counter story (in Spanish) through critical historical inquiry. Upon course completion, we gathered journey boxes, reflective written assignments and thirty minute semi-structured, recorded interviews.
Arguments
Study participants acknowledge creative tensions between the ideal citizen and their shared experiences of racism/sexism/classism and homophobia (Gutman, 2004). Findings also suggest that confronting the traditional teaching of the “good” citizen, which tends toward individualism and character, brought other conceptualizations of citizenship that focused on the communal center and affirmed the epistemic privilege of bilingual Latine teachers. Second, in reconceptualizing citizenship, a sense of belonging was redefined by oppositional identities, activism and flexible membership.
Significance
The growing multicultural mosaic provides a compelling obligation to foster an inclusive citizenry that is able to address the challenges of social justice and marginalizing patterns of citizenship education/narratives. Examining the pedagogical practices of teachers of color provides unique insights into the experiences of the communities that are foundational in furthering our democracy.