Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Critical Questions: Reconceptualizing Peer Relations in Two-Way Bilingual Programs

Sun, April 16, 2:50 to 4:20pm CDT (2:50 to 4:20pm CDT), Swissôtel Chicago, Floor: Event Centre, 1st Floor, Vevey 3

Abstract

Guadalupe Valdés gifted the field with her razor-sharp questions that could challenge
assumptions and mobilize her students, fellow scholars, and educators to advocate for minoritized bilingual students. Valdés inspired ethnographic research inside and outside bilingual classrooms to expand understanding of bilingual language learning and access to quality education. She offered insights to critically examine the social construction of language proficiency in school and the ways that peer interactions reflected the positioning, power dynamics, and systemic inequities related to race and socioeconomics that are entrenched in society surrounding schools.

Inspired by Valdés’ cautionary notes (Valdés, 1997; 2002; 2018) and her critical questions about intergroup relations in Two-Way Bilingual Education (TWBE) schools, this paper offers a reconceptualization of the ways educators and researchers examine and imagine peer relations in TWBE programs. This paper builds upon critical scholars who have shed light on the inequalities in TWBE programs and the problematic nature of interest convergence (Bell, 1980), when neoliberal/instrumentalist goals of White, middle class stakeholders are prioritized over the goals of minoritized stakeholders (Bernstein et al, 2020; Cervantes-Soon et al., 2017; Flores, 2016; Palmer, 2010; Heiman & Yanes, 2018; V. E. Valdez et al., 2016). The paper will discuss critical consciousness as taken up by Valdés and other scholars as a lens to historicize and interrogate power structures that frame TWBE goals. We reexamine and reconceptualize theoretically ‘optimal conditions’ (Allport, 1954; Pettigrew & Tropp, 2006, 2011) for intergroup relations in TWBE programs using the lens of critical consciousness to interrogate hierarchies of language, race, and class that are tied to peer relations and status in TWBE programs. The critical consciousness concepts of critical listening and embracing discomfort offer implications for reconsidering cooperation and interdependence among diverse students in TWBE programs.

Valdés’ legacy urges educators and researchers to move the field forward by interrogating
power structures that permeate schools and society. In honor of Dr. Valdés gift for asking
poignant questions, the paper ends with questions and implications for the field as we consider how/if TWBE programs can transform relations among stakeholders in schools and center the needs of multilingual learners from historically marginalized communities into the future.

Author