Search
On-Site Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Room
Browse By Unit
Browse By Session Type
About AERA 2023 Annual Meeting
Program Information
Key Dates / FAQ
Search Tips
Change Preferences / Time Zone
Sign In
Objectives and Perspectives
It is important that pre-service teachers learn to notice students’ mathematical thinking early in their teacher preparation to acquire an expertise they will need later in their professional lives (e.g., Grossman et al., 2009). Scholars recommend situating teacher preparation programs around students’ thinking (Authors, 2013). In response, we asked pre-service teachers (PSTs) to notice students’ mathematical thinking as they observe real-life mathematics classrooms. We refer to what the PSTs notice as ‘critical events’ and define these as moments in which students’ thinking becomes apparent and that teachers can use to further develop students’ understanding. We consider the following question: What characterizes the critical events that PSTs notice (attend to and interpret) during classroom observations?
We draw on research that conceptualizes noticing in terms of (a) attending to and (b) interpreting students’ mathematical thinking (Author, 2011). Teacher noticing is difficult to master, particularly because many things occur simultaneously in the classroom (Author al., 2011) involving different dimensions of teaching and learning mathematics (Op’t Eynde et al., 2006): the students’ cognitive dimension as revealed through their mathematical statements, the teacher’s cognitive dimension as revealed through methods of teaching mathematics, the students’ and the teacher’s affective dimensions, and the social dimension in which the critical event occurs. Most current frameworks consider students’ mathematics and teacher pedagogy while focusing either on attending to or on interpreting critical events. Less attention is devoted to other dimensions that may characterize both the attentional and the interpretational facets of noticing critical events.
Data Sources and Methods
The data were taken from 81 critical events reports submitted by 20 PSTs after identifying critical events during classroom observations. The reports include prompts inspired by the professional noticing framework (Jacobs et al., 2010; Author 2011). Based on this framework and a bottom-up data analysis, we constructed a three-axis model for characterizing critical events using the multiple dimensions of learning and teaching mathematics. We used this model to analyze how the PSTs attended to and interpreted students’ thinking.
Results and Significance
We found that teachers’ attention to and interpretation of critical events can be characterized using a three-axis model comprising: (a) event participants; (b) event content; and (c) cognitive, affective and social dimensions of learning and teaching mathematics. A case study taken from a PST’s (Felice) critical event report demonstrates this multidimensional characterization of attending to and interpreting critical events. The critical event Felice identified involved confusion about an issue the student ostensibly should know. Felice’s attention to the critical event was characterized by three of the model’s combinations: student mathematics cognitive; (b) teacher’s teaching strategies; and (c) student’s affective dimension. Her interpretation was also characterized by the same combinations, together with additional combinations, including the event’s social dimension and the teacher’s affective dimensions.
This work expands the body of research on what constitutes teacher noticing of critical events by characterizing how PSTs attend to and interpret critical events they identify during observations.