Search
On-Site Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Room
Browse By Unit
Browse By Session Type
About AERA 2023 Annual Meeting
Program Information
Key Dates / FAQ
Search Tips
Change Preferences / Time Zone
Sign In
Perspective and Objectives
Language provides insight into how “we base our actions…on what we take to be true” (Lakoff & Johnson, 1980, p. 160) and teachers’ stories provide insight into the multiple professional, personal, and practical truths they bring to their classroom decision-making (Clandinin & Connelly, 1996). In this study, we examine teachers’ language and reasoning about the decisions they make when using multiple curricular resources to better understand their truths.
Methods and Data Sources
Teacher interviews were analyzed as a rich source of language and reasoning. Using Quinn’s (2005) approach, we examined interview data to explore: (a) key words (e.g., repeated phrases, surprising word choices); (b) lines of reasoning (e.g., how teachers explain what they are doing); and (c) metaphors (e.g., figurative language) teachers used in explaining resource use and to capture teacher language in vignettes to use in future research and in teaching (see Appendix B for sample vignette).
Findings
Here, we focus on the data from two of the five teachers: Kasie and Jamie. For Kasie, the most repeated words were “engagement” (n = 42) and “standards” (n = 22). In explaining her curricular decision-making, Kasie plans around the standards presented in the pacing guide and the curriculum provided by the district. She worries that the materials provided to her are not engaging enough for students who are struggling in mathematics or with paying attention (as compared to “early finishers”) and seeks more engaging materials from Teachers Pay Teachers. Figuratively, she envisions mathematics as slow and methodical problem-solving “detective” work, and values building in time to explore strategies or to pause videos for discussion. Her pacing guide provides “windows” that open and close access to content.
For Jamie, the most repeated words/phrases were “standards” (n = 32) and “enjoyment” (n = 29). In explaining her reasoning, Jamie also focuses on the standards/pacing guide, but she is more likely to source alternative resources than use the provided curriculum because “when I look at all of these different places that I’m getting materials from, it helps me to broaden my look at the standard understanding”. When using the district’s materials, she thinks about the cost (e.g., feeling “guilty” for not using them) and efficiency (e.g., using materials because “they’re there”). Figuratively, mathematics is quick and efficient “ninja” work. She values concise videos, anchor charts, and task cards sourced online and the efficiency of following producers of high-quality materials on Instagram over taking time for her own searches. Her pacing guide provides “chunks” of content to be covered at particular times.
Scholarly Significance
These findings bring teacher voice and context to the researchers’ understandings of the reasoning teachers bring to making decisions across multiple curricular resources. Additionally, they demonstrate that teachers working in the same school hold different truths about both curricular resources and mathematics more generally, influencing the resources they choose to use. These findings emphasize the importance of closely attending to teachers’ language and reasoning and the value of teacher voice in both research and alternate scholarly products.