Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

The Value of Work-Related Experiential Activities During College: Comparing Traditional Versus Post-Traditional Students

Sat, April 15, 8:00 to 9:30am CDT (8:00 to 9:30am CDT), Radisson Blu Aqua Hotel, Chicago, Floor: 2nd Floor, Caribbean

Abstract

Work-related experiential activities (WREAs) are known to aid college students in gaining work experience and practical skills, and lead to varying benefits later in life (Kuh et al., 2006; Hora et al., 2017). Acknowledging this significance, higher education institutions increasingly encourage or often require students to participate in WREAs during their college years. However, many post-traditional students (Santiago et al., 2016), who enroll in colleges later than the traditional age (age > 24 while enrolled) often already have a wealth of work experience and skills, and it is unclear how additional WREAs during college will benefit this group of students. In order to support post-traditional college students’ career development more effectively, it is important to understand the students’ motivation, participation, and experiences of WREAs, and how the WREAs impact students’ career development. We conducted two quantitative studies on post-traditional students addressing participation and impact of WREAs by comparing traditional and post-traditional students’ experiences. The first study draws on the first-year dataset collected by The College Internship Study (Center for Research on College-Workforce Transitions, n.d.), which contains 3,345 students’ responses from twelve 4-year institutions between Spring 2018 and Spring 2021. This study analyzed the motivation for participating in internships, participation of WREAs (i.e., internship, coop, practicum, apprenticeship), and the impact of participation of WREAs on students’ career adaptability. The second study is based on another national dataset, Baccalaureate and Beyond 08/18, conducted by the National Center for Education Statistics (NCES, n.d.). In this study, we examined student work experiences in the last year of college, and their relationship with job satisfaction (i.e., satisfaction with compensation, work-life balance, importance of work) four years after graduation. Descriptive and inferential (i.e., linear and logistic regression) statistical analysis was used for both studies.
Both studies’ findings suggested that traditional and post-traditional students have varying motivation and participation rates for WREAs during their college years. Post-traditional students are more likely to identify themselves as primarily employees enrolled in colleges rather than working students, which is the opposite case of traditional students. Such identification implies that post-traditional students might have different motivations and reasons to participate in WREAs. Indeed, compared to traditional students, post-traditional students with WREA experiences were more often employed by private employers while enrolled in college rather than college-based WREA programs (e.g., co-op, practicum), and many of those who participated in college WREA programs did so because it was required to graduate. The findings also showed that post-traditional students’ career adaptability and post-graduate job satisfaction are generally equivalent to or even higher than those of traditional students. However, we also found that WREAs during college years often positively affect traditional students’ career outcomes, but these rarely have a significant effect on post-traditional students’ outcomes.
Our findings question the prevalent idea that WREAs are universally beneficial to college students. Based on the findings, we will discuss considerations for developing WREAs to be beneficial for post-traditional students and how college educators support them. Implications for further research on post-traditional students’ career development will also be discussed.

Authors