Search
On-Site Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Room
Browse By Unit
Browse By Session Type
About AERA 2023 Annual Meeting
Program Information
Key Dates / FAQ
Search Tips
Change Preferences / Time Zone
Sign In
For decades, educational psychologists have investigated people from racialized groups, drawing on core motivation theories to explore their academic goals, achievement choices, and aspirations. Yet many of these theories are used without the appropriate consideration of culture and race (Matthews & López, 2020). The dominating practice of inconsistently attending to the roles of culture and race in motivation is deeply problematic. Many of the traditional theories and frameworks do not account for the onto-epistemologies (i.e., the ways of knowing, doing, and being) of racialized individuals within its structures as these frameworks were developed using majority white samples (Kumar et al., 2018). In fact, being limited to no theories and frameworks rooted in perspectives that meaningfully account for the onto-epistemologies of racialized individuals presents opportunities for research to perpetuate white supremacist ideologies and practices, particularly for Black girls and women (Agger et al., 2022).
As the field of educational psychology broaches conversations and practices that promote equity and inclusion, as well as trains the next generation of scholars invested in the intersection of motivation and identity, there is evermore a need for theories and conceptual frameworks that specifically attend to the lived experiences, needs, and perspectives of marginalized people. Theories and frameworks must be situated within the lived realities of marginalized people while also remaining critical of the systems and structures that attempt to regulate and control their perspectives and experiences (DeCuir-Gunby & Schultz, 2014). In this proposal, we address a longstanding gap in the educational psychology literature by introducing a framework that critically examines the motivation and achievement choices and outcomes of Black girls, Black women, and other raced girls and women. We present “Critical Race Feminist - Situated Expectancy Value Theory” or CRF-SEVT; a framework that is based upon Critical Race Feminism (CRF; Evans-Winters & Esposito, 2010) and Situated Expectancy Value Theory (SEVT; Eccles & Wigfield, 2020).
CRF-SEVT leverages the conceptual foundation, boundaries, and beliefs of critical race feminism and the proposed internal processes of situated expectancy value theory. CRF ‘grounds and bounds’ the various constructs accounted for within SEVT–deconstructed to inputs, mediators, and outputs. CRF-SEVT:
1. Names the lived experiences of raced girls and women as credible and distinct from non-raced groups and non-women groups.
2. Considers the influence of systematic oppression on an individual’s perceptions and understandings of the self, subsequently influencing their expectations and value systems.
3. Acknowledges the multiplicative nature of identity in non-essentializing ways that would purport multiplicative consciousnesses for raced girls and women.
4. Situates socio-cultural contexts within the matrices of oppression that exist at the intersections of race, gender, class, and other targeted identities.
CRF-SEVT thus comprises three components—multiplicative identities (inputs), multiplicative consciousnesses (mediators), and expectancies and task values (outputs)—situated within particular contexts that account for the influence of intersectional forms of oppression.
Implications of this work extend beyond researching the motivation and achievement outcomes of raced girls and women within STEM (Figure 1) to also include the logics for re-envisioning educational psychology theory and praxis through critical frames.