Search
On-Site Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Room
Browse By Unit
Browse By Session Type
About AERA 2023 Annual Meeting
Program Information
Key Dates / FAQ
Search Tips
Change Preferences / Time Zone
Sign In
Purpose
An emerging design goal of college biology laboratory courses is to facilitate students exercising increased agency over building knowledge in, and manipulating the materials of, scientific investigations (Author, 2022; Hester et al., 2018). Investigations in these settings are typically conducted by small groups of students (Author, 2022) or entire classes. This can create tensions within a group of who gets to exercise agency in deciding the trajectory of an investigation (refer to Berland and Hammer (2012), for an example of this tension emerging between a classroom of students and an instructor). There is a design need to understand how this tension plays out in small groups (e.g., Conlin & Scherr, 2018), in order to structure curricula which provide all students opportunities to exercise agency over the conduct of scientific investigations. In this poster we start to address this need through a case study of a freshman biology student, Alaad, who experiences this tension with his group, and finds space to exercise agency over building knowledge through engagement with a computer simulation.
Theoretical framework
We locate agency in students’ ability to contribute to the construction of knowledge in (epistemic agency) and the conduct of (decision-making agency) an investigation (Author, 2021; Author, 2022). Following Miller et al. (2018) (and with inspiration from Ko and Krist (2019)) we consider “ability to contribute” as comprising curricula positioning students to contribute, students perceiving themselves as enabled to contribute, and students acting to make contributions. Furthermore, we identify students’ framing of a learning space—their expectations of what’s going on in that space—as a factor contributing to students' perception of the kinds of contributions that are appropriate to make (Author, 2021; Holmes, 2020).
Method & Data sources
We characterize the contributions of group members to knowledge building and decision making in two parts of their investigation (experimental design in week 2, and data analysis in week 3) through analysis of in-class video and lab reports. In order to foreground the tension between individual and group agency we mark out which individual students made bids to contribute, which contributions were taken up by the group (both in the moment and in their lab reports), which were not, and why. We supplement these characterizations with data from a semi-structured interview with the focal student, Alaad. This provides insights into Alaad’s perceptions of his own agency and his framing of the activity.
Substantiated conclusions & Scholarly significance
In this case study we describe how the focal student, Alaad, found space to contribute to knowledge building about the study system, despite tensions with a group which prioritized simplicity and certainty of a particular outcome in their experimental design. We identify that the computer simulation served as a niche in which he could exercise epistemic agency, after being excluded from decision-making in the experimental design. This suggests that structuring an investigation around multiple data production modalities can provide opportunities for more students within a group to contribute to building knowledge in and directing the conduct of that investigation.