Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

How Shifts in Physical Positions Can Indicate Shifts in Authority, Agency, and Power (Poster 3)

Fri, April 14, 9:50 to 11:20am CDT (9:50 to 11:20am CDT), Radisson Blu Aqua Hotel, Chicago, Floor: 1st Floor, Atlantic E

Abstract

Purpose

This poster contributes to emerging work theorizing the role of physical positioning in relation to agency and authority in learning, particularly in groupwork interactions. Previous research has identified how physical proximity to others, materials, and movement are associated with the epistemic framing of tasks, whose ideas are valued, and roles or positions of group members (Engle et al., 2014; Kelly et al., 2020; Langer-Osuna et al., 2016). We build on this work to explore: How are shifts in physical positioning associated with shifts in authority and/or expressions of agency?

Theoretical framework

We focus on the constructs of authority and agency from an interactional perspective with respect to learning and knowledge. This focus provides opportunities to examine their dynamaticity (i.e., shifts) set within a more static context (e.g., normativity), highlighting how power is at work in interaction. By authority, we refer to the social power to give information or request actions in a way that is unquestioned by others (Kinser-Traut & Turner, 2020; Wagner & Herbel-Eisenmann, 2014). Related to authority, agency refers to the capacity of an individual to behave in a way that is self-directed, with epistemic agency related to initiating or directing knowledge building (e.g., posing problems, suggesting novel solutions, and testing uncertain claims (Damşa et al., 2010; Stroupe, 2014).

Method & Data sources

The data analyzed include audio and video recordings of several lessons in one teacher’s mathematics classroom with 10th and 11th grade students. This poster presents two episodes selected in which the teacher was interacting with a small group while the students explored mathematical ideas (refer to Dyer et al. (2021) for more detailed analysis). We conducted a close analysis of shifts in physical positioning (e.g., body movement, location), shifts in epistemic agency (e.g., who takes up the search for knowledge), and shifts in epistemic authority (e.g., whose intellectual ideas were taken up by the group).

Substantiated conclusions & Scholarly significance

Both episodes demonstrate the co-occurrence of shifts in physical positioning with significant shifts in authority and expressions of agency as part of groupwork. The first episode provides an example of shifts in the teacher’s physical position (e.g., from upright, to leaning back, to bending forward), which strongly corresponded to shifts in epistemic authority from teacher to a pair of students and their related expressions of epistemic agency while suggesting and then exploring a potential solution. The second episode provides an example of how shifts in a student’s physical position corresponded to that student’s expression of agency (sharing a novel solution strategy) and his related shift in epistemic authority within the group.

These episodes provide evidence that shifts between physical positions can indicate meaningful moments in terms of shift in agency and authority, and thus power. This analytic method can serve as a way of screening for indicators of important transitional moments during episodes that can then be further unpacked in terms of agency, authority, and power in interaction. Furthermore, these findings suggest the value in considering agency from an embodied perspective.

Authors