Paper Summary
Share...

Direct link:

From Self-Blame to Institutional Critiques: Black Girls Reframing Their Educational Experiences Through Movement

Sun, April 16, 4:40 to 6:10pm CDT (4:40 to 6:10pm CDT), Swissôtel Chicago, Floor: Event Centre, 1st Floor, St. Gallen 2

Abstract

Black girls disproportionately inhabit schooling contexts that diminish their academic potential and dehumanize their Black girlhood. Having to navigate these systems of sexism and anti-Blackness in school has adverse effects on their academic outcomes and self-perceptions, as some of them may blame themselves for perceived academic failures (Tyson 2011; Morris 2015; Wun 2016). Yet, scholars have found that as Black girls develop a critical consciousness, or “an awareness of how institutional, historical and systemic forces, limit and promote life opportunities for particular groups” (Ginwright & Cammarota 2002), they gain the ability to shift their lens from self-blame to critiques of the school policies and practices that actively harm them. Though existing research points to the importance of out-of-school spaces as sites where Black girls can develop this critical consciousness (Ginwright 2007; Brown 2013; Price-Dennis, et al. 2017), we still know far too little about how their constant movement between — and their continuous emplacement within — both sites inform their assessments of their educational journeys.

This paper investigates how Black girls develop the peer relationships, insights, and language needed to critically examine the institutional contexts that create the conditions for their academic trajectories. Drawing on 15-months of ethnographic fieldwork with 45 high school-aged Black girls in the New York City metro area, I highlight how Black girls’ movement between school and The Sadie Nash Leadership Project, a social justice-centered afterschool program, provides them with multiple opportunities to reflect on and develop the language to reframe their schooling experiences. My findings reveal that Black girls are constantly observing and reassessing their educational environments and that rather than experience schooling and Sadie Nash as discrete locations, they merge and layer their experiences in both sites. That is, I argue that it is not solely their participation in Sadie Nash that enables them to critically examine their in-school experiences, but their multiple emplacements in both sites, and ability to reflect on and contrast these distinct educational environments. I identify three ways in which Black girls’ movement between school and Sadie Nash aids in the development of their critical consciousness, focusing on how this movement offers them the opportunity to 1) engage in dialogue with other youth who attend less (and more) punitive schools, 2) learn history and language that accurately contextualizes their previous schooling experiences, and 3) be embedded in a positive and affirming educational environment that provides an alternate mode of learning. These findings build and extend existing research on Black girlhood and out-of-school learning spaces by emphasizing the importance of out-of-school spaces as alternatives to hostile schooling and by positioning movement as a key meaning-making process that enables Black girls to (re)examine and reframe their schooling experiences.

Author