Search
On-Site Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Room
Browse By Unit
Browse By Session Type
About AERA 2023 Annual Meeting
Program Information
Key Dates / FAQ
Search Tips
Change Preferences / Time Zone
Sign In
Purpose
This presentation describes an efficacy study design, assessment plan, and impacts on teachers and students of a biology intervention that included RA PD and science curriculum design (Goldman, Greenleaf et al, 2019).
Theoretical Framework
Science texts are used for reasoning about scientific phenomena. Meaningful interaction with science texts is needed to develop students’ domain knowledge and science literacy for successful science learning. Research on effective comprehension instruction calls for flexibly adaptive teaching that is neither commonplace nor simple (Heller & Greenleaf, 2007).
Methods
Design. This semester-long RCT tested the effects of RA’s PD augmented with curricular models against normal educational practice. Intervention teachers received 10 days of PD, support during intervention, and instructional models. Teachers’ knowledge, attitudes, and practices were assessed using surveys and classroom observation. All teachers’ baseline assessment occurred pre-intervention. For treatment teachers, the “post” assessment occurred after the intervention. Student baseline data were collected within the first four weeks of school and within two weeks after the intervention.
Data Sources
Teacher Assessments. We developed and administered a self-report survey that tapped teacher knowledge, attitudes, and practices for teaching science, science literacy, and their students. We conducted two classroom observations with a 6-construct protocol.
Student Assessments. We administered RISE, a general reading skill assessment (Sabatini, et al., 2013) to investigate intervention impact on basic reading skills (e.g., word recognition, vocabulary). The GISA was administered post intervention (Sabatini & O’Reilly, 2015).
Participants. Schools were recruited from 6 urban and suburban districts. Within strata created based on achievement and socioeconomics, schools were randomly assigned to Intervention or Control, producing 12 schools and 24 teachers of 9th grade biology in each condition. 1400~ students contributed analyzable data (60% Intervention).
Results
Intervention students were better equipped to tackle new texts in the biology domain with ES=.26 for the multiple choice task and .32 for the GISA. Estimates of the magnitude of change associated with one year of reading growth at the high school level are .19. Intervention students were about 1.5 years ahead of the Control students after participation.
Surveys. Intervention teachers scored significantly higher than Control teachers on Higher-order Teaching Practices, with large effect sizes (1.34 < d > 2.00) at post-test. Intervention teachers indicated that they provided a variety of science reading opportunities more frequently than the Control teachers, also with a large effect size, d = 1.37.
Classroom observations. Significant differences between Intervention and Control teachers on all constructs, with large effect sizes, were observed. Intervention teachers’ mode of instruction was a mix of teacher-directed activity (modeling a think aloud, introducing a new practice) and student collaborative activity (metacognitive conversations around text, peer review). Control teachers’ mode of instruction was teacher-lecture.
Significance
Shifts in positioning of texts, tasks, and students’ roles as agentive learners are needed to enhance science literacy practices needed for explanatory modeling. These shifts are possible but require time and learning opportunities for teachers as well as students.