Search
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Policy Area
Browse By Session Type
Browse By Keyword
Browse Artificial Intelligence Presentations
Program Calendar
Sign In
Search Tips
Institutions participating in federal aid programs must publish a Cost of Attendance (COA) that includes an estimated off-campus living allowance. Unlike tuition, this figure is an estimate rather than a price, yet it communicates what attendance costs, enters need calculations, and limits borrowing through programs such as Parent PLUS. Prior cross-sectional studies document large departures from external cost estimates but leave unresolved whether they persist, whether nearby institutions’ figures move together, and how they respond to institutional resources.
Drawing on bounded rationality, institutional theory, and resource dependence, we compare IPEDS living-cost reports from 2,243 four-year institutions (2010 to 2023) with an external benchmark built from HUD, USDA, BEA, BLS, and KFF data. We use spatial panel models with institution and year fixed effects and a Bartik shift-share instrument for state appropriations.
Public institutions report above the benchmark on average and private institutions below it. Among institutions observed for at least ten years, private institutions are more than twice as likely as public institutions to report below the benchmark in every observed year (24.6 versus 10.4 percent). Public institutions’ reported costs move together with nearby public institutions’ over time, including across state lines; private institutions show no comparable co-movement. A $1,000 decline in state appropriations per FTE student reduces public institutions’ reported living costs by $905 and the benchmark by $543, so reported allowances fall $362 more than the benchmark.
The findings support documented estimation methods, common reference budgets, and review of allowance revisions when state funding changes.