Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Access and What Follows: Federal and Non-Profit College Access Programs Across the Educational Pipeline

Friday, November 6, 3:30 to 5:00pm, Property: Boston Marriott Copley Place, Floor: 5th Floor, Room: Massachusetts

Abstract

Federal college access programs have been proposed for elimination on the argument that access to college is no longer the main obstacle for low-income students. Using the High School Longitudinal Study of 2009 and doubly robust estimators with machine-learned nuisance models, this study compares three federal programs (Talent Search, Upward Bound, GEAR UP) with two non-profit alternatives (AVID, MESA) and with non-participation, on outcomes spanning the high-school-to-college pipeline. Talent Search participation is associated with 5.9 percentage points higher college entry, but beyond entry, federal participants are indistinguishable from non-participants. Head-to-head, federal participants outperform non-profit participants in advanced high school science credits and mathematics grades, selective four-year enrollment, and college science credits attempted and earned. These gaps arise because non-profit participants fall below comparable non-participants. The gaps are sensitive to modest unobserved differences and smaller and less precise when survey-weighted. The results do not support treating the non-profit programs observed here as substitutes for federal programs, and effects differ enough across programs that funding decisions are better informed program by program than for programs as a class.

Author