Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Poster #13 - Fine Particulate Matter Pollution and Domestic Violence

Saturday, November 7, 12:00 to 1:30pm, Property: Boston Marriott Copley Place, Floor: 4th Floor, Room: Grand Ballroom - Salon EFG

Abstract

Understanding the determinants of domestic violence, a crime that has significant and long-lasting negative physical and psychological health effects on victims and spillover effects on their families, is a crucial first step towards minimizing the incidence of this socially costly crime. Previous research on determinants of domestic violence has identified sources of increased stress (e.g., change in timing of social safety net disbursements, COVID-19 lockdowns) and reduced cognition (e.g., alcohol) as resulting in increases in domestic violence. In this paper, we study the impacts of an environmental cause of reduced cognition on the incidence of domestic violence: fine particulate matter pollution, or PM2.5.
The medical, epidemiology, and economics literatures have established a direct causal link between PM2.5 and emotional regulation, impulse control, depression, temperament, and cognition. PM2.5 is small enough to cross the blood-brain barrier, reducing the amount of oxygen available to the brain and causing neuro-inflammation. Brain imaging scans have documented immediate reductions in neural activity throughout many parts of the brain as a result of heightened PM2.5 exposure. Previous work in economics and other literatures has documented how the cognitive impacts of PM2.5 translate into real-world outcomes, as measured by increases in other types of crime and violent behavior, worse real-time decision-making, and worse student performance on exams.

To causally identify the impact of PM2.5 exposure on domestic violence, our identification strategy uses an instrumental variables approach that leverages jurisdiction-level changes in wind direction to generate predicted measures of pollution. Wind direction affects pollution levels in an area because pollutants upwind of the area will be carried downwind, and changes in wind direction affect how much pollution is upwind. Fine particulate matter can travel long distances (sometimes thousands of miles) so this includes pollutants from nonlocal sources, which strengthens the validity of the instrument, as long-distance pollution is uncorrelated with factors that could affect the outcomes (e.g., places with higher baseline levels of pollution tend to be in lower-income areas, which are also places that tend to have higher reported rates of domestic violence).
We will combine high-frequency pollution data from the EPA and CDC with 911 calls for service from law enforcement agencies across the U.S. and reported domestic violence incidents in the National Incident-Based Reporting System (NIBRS). We have thus far compiled records of 911 calls for service from over 100 law enforcement agencies through a combination of public records requests and downloading publicly available data. Domestic violence is notoriously underreported, so by combining calls for potential incidents with reported crimes we can more accurately determine the relationship between PM2.5 and this serious crime.

The results will have important policy implications in terms of potentially identifying another determinant of domestic violence. In doing so, we will also paint a clearer picture of the costs of fine particulate matter pollution. If fine particulate matter pollution does lead to increases in domestic violence, that implies the socially optimal level of fine particulate matter pollution is lower than previously believed.

Author