Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

State Policy Change and the Use of Alternative Sanctions in Texas Municipal Courts

Thursday, November 5, 8:30 to 10:00am, Property: Boston Marriott Copley Place, Floor: 5th Floor, Room: Maine

Abstract

Class C misdemeanors, which are Texas’s lowest criminal offense, consisting largely of speeding tickets, represent the biggest proportion of criminal legal contact in the state, yet remain one of the least-studied dimensions of the Texas criminal legal system. Recent work on fine-only offenses highlights their disproportionate impact on underrepresented communities and role in perpetuating the criminalization of poverty. In 2017, amid increasing attention to the use of arrest warrants in these fine-only cases, the Texas Legislature passed House Bill 351 to mitigate some of the most severe consequences of Class C misdemeanor charges, but the impact of this policy has yet to be tested empirically. This study contributes to research on state-to-local policy implementation by asking whether HB 351 changes the use of alternative sanctions, and how these impacts vary across the state. Using data from the Office of Court Administration from 952 municipalities we estimate the aggregate policy effect and heterogeneity across jurisdictions. Our findings suggest that, on average, HB 351 is associated with a decrease in arrest warrants and jail credit, while the policy is also associated with an increase in community service and fee waivers. However, the magnitude of these estimates vary across municipalities suggesting that state-wide reform may have uneven local implementation. These findings reveal the limits of state-level reform in reaching local courts uniformly and underscore the need for more data on low-level legal contact.

Authors