Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Poster #20 - Monitoring Broadly and Lobbying Narrowly? Political Environment and Labor’s State-Level Agenda Setting

Saturday, November 7, 12:00 to 1:30pm, Property: Boston Marriott Copley Place, Floor: 4th Floor, Room: Grand Ballroom - Salon EFG

Abstract

Among the only organized interests representing the working class, labor unions can function as representatives of this large and heterogeneous group in policy decision making. Historically, labor unions have had an especially strong alliance with the national Democratic Party. Scholars have shown how labor union agendas in national U.S. politics have been shaped by their relationship with the Democratic Party. Although union membership has declined in recent decades, labor unions still play an important role in politics at the national level. We know less, however, about labor union policy actions at the state level. During this time of inequality and political uncertainty and given unions’ potential to improve outcomes for working Americans, it is vital to understand how unions plan their policy advocacy. Given longstanding partisan gridlock at the federal level and a presidential administration that is unfriendly towards labor, advocacy for labor and social policy is likely to be driven to the state level. This study examines the agenda development processes of labor unions at the state level, with a particular focus on the role that the political environment plays in agenda setting processes. I develop a conceptual framework and study propositions based on the three theoretical perspectives—the agenda setting model, political opportunity structure, and extended party network theory. I then utilize a qualitative study design to examine how labor unions consider their political opportunity structures, their party alliances, and their coalition partners in their state level agenda decisions. I investigate labor agenda setting in two states, one in which the Democratic Party has strong control, Massachusetts, and one in which there is political competition between political parties, Michigan. Data for this study will come from one-on-one semi-structured interviews with 20 key informants who are staff members of labor unions that engage in lobbying in each state. To analyze interview data, I will perform thematic coding using the qualitative analysis software Dedoose. The findings from key informant interviews will help me to refine the conceptual framework. This study will make several contributions to the academic interest group advocacy literature and to our understanding of labor union public policy priorities. Academic contributions will include both a better understanding of the internal agenda development process and of the activities of interest groups at the state level. The results of this study will also shed light on a common disagreement about the nature of labor unions’ policy activity—are they a special interest group, or do they represent a broader social constituency?

Author