Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Trust the Police?: Signaling Procedural Justice through Policy Change

Thursday, November 5, 8:30 to 10:00am, Property: Boston Marriott Copley Place, Floor: 5th Floor, Room: Maine

Abstract

Traffic stops for regulatory violations, such as a broken taillight or expired registration, disproportionately affect drivers of color, which can contribute to perceptions of bias in policing. In turn, such perceptions can decrease trust in police, lower willingness to cooperate with police, decrease perceptions of police legitimacy, and threaten police-community relationships. In 2022, community groups in Mecklenburg County, North Carolina brought data on racial disparities in regulatory traffic stops made by the Mecklenburg County Sheriff’s Office (MCSO) to the sheriff. The community groups proposed ending the use of regulatory stops, and in September 2022, the sheriff announced that MCSO had ended the use of regulatory violations as the primary reason for a traffic stop. This policy change serves as a signal of MCSO’s commitment to procedural justice, highlighting four key components of a procedurally just policy: giving citizens a voice in the policymaking process, trustworthiness of the legal authorities, neutral and unbiased decision-making, and treatment of citizens with dignity and respect. When announcing the policy change, the sheriff explicitly stated two policy goals: reducing racial disparities and increasing traffic safety. The current study uses MCSO traffic stop data and Mecklenburg County serious traffic crash data from September 2021 to September 2023 to evaluate the impact of the policy change and whether it accomplished its stated goals. An interrupted time series analysis found that ending the use of regulatory traffic stops decreased racial disparities and increased the number of safety-related stops but did not significantly affect the number of serious crashes. These findings suggest an overall positive impact of the policy change, though the effect on traffic safety is mixed. While the policy was not fully successful in accomplishing its goals, a policy with a mixed evidence base can still have benefits. The policy did not have a negative impact on traffic safety, and the subjective benefits associated with the policy are harder to measure, but are equally as important. The sheriff’s announcement of the policy signaled MSCO’s commitment to procedural justice, which contributes to improved police-community relationships. Next steps include fielding a public opinion survey to measure the impact of procedural justice signals on citizens’ perceptions of legal authorities.

Author